Who would you rather have on your team?

[John la Rock]

I'd go with A-Rod but I love Pujols as well. They are equal when it comes to hitting but Rodriguez is a harder worker, and much better defencively

I'd say they are the 2 best players in the majors.

[BCWWF]

I choose Pujols because I believe he is younger? He can play three positions, and IMO a more dominant hitter than A-Rod.

[Supreme Olajuwon]

ARod because of his defense

A dominant shortstop is harder to come across than a dominant outfielder or first baseman

[John la Rock]

well thirdbaseman now

[MoRcHeEbA]

why can't I just have both players... They do play different positions

[Loose Cannon]

I guess A-Rod. Tough choice.

[DaveWadding]

ARod because of his defense

A dominant shortstop is harder to come across than a dominant outfielder or first baseman
Pujols is capable of playing 3rd too :p

[The Icon of Elisim]

Pujols, he strikes me as a better team player

[Ben]

I'm a Cards fan, but as much as I :heart: Pujols, I'd have to say A-Rod. Pujols has had a better start to his career, but you gotta go with a SS/3B over 1B/3B/LF, especially when he hits as well as A-Rod... Cause you can always find a good 1B or LF to go with A-Rod, but if you take Pujols, can you get another good SS?

[Heyman]

I'd go with A-Rod but I love Pujols as well. They are equal when it comes to hitting but Rodriguez is a harder worker, and much better defencively

I'd say they are the 2 best players in the majors.


Pujols. He's MUCH cheaper.

[The Miz]

If we're not including contracts, Alex Rodriguez. Both bring around the same offense to the table, but I'd much rather have an excellent defensive SS/3B than an above average corner infielder/outfielder. Rodriguez also has more speed.

[John la Rock]

Pujols. He's MUCH cheaper.

No money, contratcts, endorsement deals whatever

Talent only

[Oxstar]

I don't have a clue about baseball but I voted for Alex Rodriguez

[John la Rock]

Pujols is capable of playing 3rd too :p

ya but he's not a goldglove infielder like A-Rod

[YOUR Hero]

Gotta give the edge to ARod.

[Supreme Olajuwon]

Not really much to do with the topic but I would rather have Vlad Guerrero on my team than Pujols

[BCWWF]

Vlad > Anyone

For that matter

[John la Rock]

ya I'd put Vlady as # 3 best player after A-Rod and Pujols