TPWW Forums

TPWW Forums (https://www.tpwwforums.com/index.php)
-   entertainment forum (https://www.tpwwforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Lost - Season 5 - Someone get Jack a drink! (https://www.tpwwforums.com/showthread.php?t=85694)

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 11:18 AM

I bet Jack wakes up on the plane, and it was all a dream!

Book it, we will get fucked with that

El Fangel 01-23-2009 11:27 AM

Im not sure about this, but when the time was skipping back and forth for Locke at the plane. I think for Sawyers group the hatch was imploded.

Wouldnt the plane that Locke was leaning against have been burned out?

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fallen Angel (Post 2408365)
Im not sure about this, but when the time was skipping back and forth for Locke at the plane. I think for Sawyers group the hatch was imploded.

Wouldnt the plane that Locke was leaning against have been burned out?

I think the Plane gets burned after the Hatch, shortly before Eko dies me thought.

wwe2222 01-23-2009 01:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanso (Post 2408355)
Anyone else think there were way too many people in the 70s Dharma Initiative......Like, what happened to the construction guys....they didnt seem to be in on it....where did they go and why havent they ever talked?

I assume they were killed by Hostiles at some point or died in the Purge along with everyone else.

wwe2222 01-23-2009 01:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanso (Post 2408327)
I think Richard was meant to be a huge part of the show....as was Mr. Eko, before they both left for other shows. But Cane failed, so Richard is back and can finally play his role.

I believe they've signed Nestor Carbonell who plays Richard to a deal so he wont disappear from the story anymore.

Mr. Eko wanted to leave the show as did the actress who played Rousseau (or so I read).

I love his character and was upset when he left to be on Cane. Thank goodness that got canceled.

Corporate CockSnogger 01-23-2009 01:28 PM

Anyone else thinking Ms Hawking is Faradays mother?

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 02:22 PM

I thought the same thing, but the way Ben got to her within minutes of being in LA, I dont think she is in Oxford.

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 02:22 PM

And faradays mom is in Oxford.

I think Hawking will end up being some kind of Keeper of Time, and Ben is a servant.

Corporate CockSnogger 01-23-2009 02:26 PM

Yeah that was the only downside to my theory about that aswell. But wasn't the scene when Desmond woke up with Penny on the boat not long after the O6 got back to the 'real world', whereas the scene with Ms Hawking and Ben was 3 years after that, so maybe Desmond has already found her by this point and since then she's moved.

Supreme Olajuwon 01-23-2009 02:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Requiem (Post 2408248)
IMO, Richard is just like the other 'others'. They've been resetting back in time for a long time and thus do not age. There was a point when the others were talking and someone said "Remember when we used to celebrate birthdays" or something like that. They have been there so long probably that most of them should be pretty old by now, if not dead, yet they have not aged except internally. (IE - the woman with the 80 or so year old womb)

Basically, back when he visited Locke as a child, he was at the age he went onto the island. He has just stayed the same age, only aging when they leave the island (as they are able to do). Richard seems like a very important character, so it is not surprising that he is able to come and go as he pleases, just like Ben.

Richard is one of my favorite 'non-major' characters though. Pretty cool guy, and I hope he gets to be in the spotlight for a while this season.

Yeah but Richard appears to be something above the rest of the Others. Like how in the last episode he knew Locke was shot but Locke never told him. The writers on this show have never been subtle about foreshadowing so I have to assume that this scene means Richard is something special.

thedamndest 01-23-2009 03:40 PM

I wonder what's going to happen with Hurley. I mean it could be nothing, but why go to the trouble of bringing back Ana Lucia and warning him specifically not to get arrested only to have him turn himself in to the police?

El Fangel 01-23-2009 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Iginfest (Post 2408530)
Yeah that was the only downside to my theory about that aswell. But wasn't the scene when Desmond woke up with Penny on the boat not long after the O6 got back to the 'real world', whereas the scene with Ms Hawking and Ben was 3 years after that, so maybe Desmond has already found her by this point and since then she's moved.

Everyone posts my thoughts like 2 hours before I get it worked out in my head. Well here is my thoughts.

Ms Hawking is Faradays mother, when you see Ben with her this is circa 3 years after the Oceanic 6 made it off the island.

I am guessing/theorizing that what happened is Faraday told Desmond to go to Oxford, which he did I am guessing. (I guessing he met with Ms Hawking then shortly after in off island time we see Ben talking to Ms Hawking about bringing them back)

I am guessing that Ms Hawking knows for things to correct themselves on the island, all the people who were on the island before it moved has to be back on the island for the timeline to correct itself, I think it keeps skipping because when it resets to a different time, there is a flaw in the timeline (the oceanic 6 missing) so it again tries to reset itself to correct the island, but that wont happen unless the oceanic 6, including Locke and Ben also has to be on the island for when the island resets (moves in time) looking for the right time where the oceanic six where on the island. It wont find this as they are not on the island in any time period anymore, so the island will continue to move back and forth until the oceanic six are returned to the island.

I am guessing Ms Hawkings comment refers to what will happen if they are not all returned. Which I think is.

During the episode the constant, Desmond starts to die because he does not have a constant yet.

During the second episode, we see Faradays girl with a nose-bleed, which foreshawows what will happen ala desmond in the constant.

Ms Hawking knows that the island will continue resetting or trying to fix itself until the oceanic six are back on the island, which is doing to all the current inhabitants on the island what happened to Desmond during "The Constant" she knows in a short while, without constants these people will die.

Which is why she tells Ben he has only 70 hours (roughly a few days like Desmond had) before time runs out (the island inhabitants die)

Thats my guess, I would love for you to tell me what you think

wwe2222 01-23-2009 04:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supreme Olajuwon (Post 2408535)
Yeah but Richard appears to be something above the rest of the Others. Like how in the last episode he knew Locke was shot but Locke never told him. The writers on this show have never been subtle about foreshadowing so I have to assume that this scene means Richard is something special.

from Lostpedia...

"In the Season 3 DVD commentary for "The Man from Tallahassee", Richard Alpert is described as someone who is not interested in leading the Others but is very influential in finding and selecting a leader. In the commentary for "The Man from Tallahassee", he is described as being similar to a Panchen Lama choosing the next Dalai Lama. He and Ben keep each other in "check" by having the power to pick/veto each other's replacement on the Island. Ben's role would be to pick the next Panchen, should the need arise. This keeps the two in a sort of balanced power relationship. They are allies, yet they have some measure of control over the other should one get out of hand."

also...
"Richard is the only living Other known to have belonged to the Hostiles who has been identified by name."

Im not sure if Richard is one of the original inhabitans of the island, but I imagine most of them are like him, except he just happens to be the one with the most power (among the original Hostiles)

wwe2222 01-23-2009 04:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fallen Angel (Post 2408628)
Everyone posts my thoughts like 2 hours before I get it worked out in my head. Well here is my thoughts.

Ms Hawking is Faradays mother, when you see Ben with her this is circa 3 years after the Oceanic 6 made it off the island.

I am guessing/theorizing that what happened is Faraday told Desmond to go to Oxford, which he did I am guessing. (I guessing he met with Ms Hawking then shortly after in off island time we see Ben talking to Ms Hawking about bringing them back)

Actually Penny mentions after Desmond wakes up from his dream that he has been off the Island for three years already. That presumably puts him in the same time frame as Ben visiting Hawking.

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 04:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Iginfest (Post 2408530)
Yeah that was the only downside to my theory about that aswell. But wasn't the scene when Desmond woke up with Penny on the boat not long after the O6 got back to the 'real world', whereas the scene with Ms Hawking and Ben was 3 years after that, so maybe Desmond has already found her by this point and since then she's moved.

When he wakes up Penny mentions it has been 3 years...so it is current.

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supreme Olajuwon (Post 2408535)
Yeah but Richard appears to be something above the rest of the Others. Like how in the last episode he knew Locke was shot but Locke never told him. The writers on this show have never been subtle about foreshadowing so I have to assume that this scene means Richard is something special.

Richard tells Locke that Locke told him where he would be....so like Locke will jump, and tell Richard to be in that field at that time to remove the bullet...So locke sets it up, but it hasnt happened yet.

Kind of a Bill and Ted moment...

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedamndest (Post 2408607)
I wonder what's going to happen with Hurley. I mean it could be nothing, but why go to the trouble of bringing back Ana Lucia and warning him specifically not to get arrested only to have him turn himself in to the police?

I think somehow Cops are going to be working for Widmore.

Hanso Amore 01-23-2009 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wwe2222 (Post 2408651)
Actually Penny mentions after Desmond wakes up from his dream that he has been off the Island for three years already. That presumably puts him in the same time frame as Ben visiting Hawking.

Right.

Which basically blows the Faradays mom thing out of the water.

it couldstill happen, but I am thinking Faradays mom will be on the side of the Losties, where as Hawking is seemingly with the Others/Ben, whom I am thinking more and more are some kind of Time Line Guardians, or perhaps people that have gone back in time and need to make sure nothing changes so that that time can get back to the future where they left.

Like if the world changes before they originally left, they cease to exist...

El Fangel 01-23-2009 05:26 PM

I said that when Penny and Desmond are on the boat its shortly before (maybe a few days or less) what is happening in the first 2 episodes of season 5.

To put this in perspective as not to get it confused. (using my own dates)

January 1st/2000 - Oceanic six leave the island
December 27th/2002 - Faraday tells Desmond to talk to his Mom
December 31st/2002 - Desmond talks to Ms Hawking (Faradays mom) tells her what is going on
January 1st/2003 - Ms Hawlkin/Ben/Locke all try to get the six back to the island


thedamndest 01-23-2009 05:50 PM

Your dates are off. They leave the island in 2004. Desmond has his dream three years later, so presumably that's when he goes to Oxford. Same with everybody trying to get back to the island. As far as Faraday talking to Desmond, I don't know. Probably after he killed the other guy since he was so paranoid about another person showing up.

El Fangel 01-23-2009 06:05 PM

I said that when Penny and Desmond are on the boat its shortly before (maybe a few days or less) what is happening in the first 2 episodes of season 5.

To put this in perspective as not to get it confused. (using my own dates)

January 1st/2000 - Oceanic six leave the island
December 27th/2002 - Faraday tells Desmond to talk to his Mom
December 31st/2002 - Desmond talks to Ms Hawking (Faradays mom) tells her what is going on
January 1st/2003 - Ms Hawlkin/Ben/Locke all try to get the six back to the island

Quote:

Originally Posted by Theddy
Your dates are off. They leave the island in 2004. Desmond has his dream three years later, so presumably that's when he goes to Oxford. Same with everybody trying to get back to the island. As far as Faraday talking to Desmond, I don't know. Probably after he killed the other guy since he was so paranoid about another person showing up.


I said using my own dates as perspective. What I am saying is in sequence of events in a normal timeline, this happened

Faraday talked to Desmond in the past
Desmond has his "flashback"
Desmond talks to Faradays mom/Ms Hawking
Ms Hawking/Ben/Locke attempt to get the O6 back on the island

thedamndest 01-23-2009 06:08 PM

Yeah, but you could just use the dates the show gives.

El Fangel 01-23-2009 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedamndest (Post 2408740)
Yeah, but you could just use the dates the show gives.

I couldnt remember the exact dates. :-\

thedamndest 01-23-2009 06:26 PM

I KNEW IT!

I've been reading lostpedia like crazy, probably gonna have to rewatch episodes soon enough. I didn't remember Ms. Hawking at all. I just thought she was some random Jedi lady who liked her scented candles and pendulums. Yeah, gonna need to rewatch.

wwe2222 01-24-2009 12:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedamndest (Post 2408753)
I KNEW IT!

I've been reading lostpedia like crazy, probably gonna have to rewatch episodes soon enough. I didn't remember Ms. Hawking at all. I just thought she was some random Jedi lady who liked her scented candles and pendulums. Yeah, gonna need to rewatch.

I could spend hours on lostpedia. It really adds to the enjoyment of the show because it gives you so many little things you wouldnt always catch.

El Fangel 01-24-2009 03:10 AM

Lostpedia? Links bitches and rep will be giveth.

thedamndest 01-24-2009 03:50 AM

Type "lostpedia.com" into your browser and press enter.

Requiem 01-24-2009 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supreme Olajuwon (Post 2408535)
Yeah but Richard appears to be something above the rest of the Others. Like how in the last episode he knew Locke was shot but Locke never told him. The writers on this show have never been subtle about foreshadowing so I have to assume that this scene means Richard is something special.

This seemed pretty straightforward to me. The compass pointed toward Locke, in case you didn't notice, and he told Locke to give it to him when he saw him next even though he wouldn't know who he was. This says to me that Locke get sent back in time, and gives the compass to Richard and tells him about what happens, which is how Richard finds him later.

Hanso Amore 01-24-2009 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Requiem (Post 2409251)
This seemed pretty straightforward to me. The compass pointed toward Locke, in case you didn't notice, and he told Locke to give it to him when he saw him next even though he wouldn't know who he was. This says to me that Locke get sent back in time, and gives the compass to Richard and tells him about what happens, which is how Richard finds him later.

Yup.

thedamndest 01-25-2009 05:58 PM

I thought Richard just took the compass out of his pocket and gave it to Locke. Maybe it's just Richard's compass and he knows it will convince his other self that Locke is telling the truth. He shouldn't have had any trouble locating Locke in physical location because when Locke tells him where he is with the bullet in his leg, he will tell him to look by the plane. Locke doesn't know the time, so the question is, has Richard been coming every night to check for a bleeding Locke?

Also, did anyone else not believe Sun when she said she forgave Kate? She will have to return to the island, but if Ben is right in front of her, she would have the opportunity to kill him then. Could that mean that she and Widmore now want to possess the island?

I am pretty convinced that Jack is Jacob.

wwe2222 01-26-2009 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedamndest (Post 2410388)
I thought Richard just took the compass out of his pocket and gave it to Locke. Maybe it's just Richard's compass and he knows it will convince his other self that Locke is telling the truth. He shouldn't have had any trouble locating Locke in physical location because when Locke tells him where he is with the bullet in his leg, he will tell him to look by the plane. Locke doesn't know the time, so the question is, has Richard been coming every night to check for a bleeding Locke?

Also, did anyone else not believe Sun when she said she forgave Kate? She will have to return to the island, but if Ben is right in front of her, she would have the opportunity to kill him then. Could that mean that she and Widmore now want to possess the island?

I am pretty convinced that Jack is Jacob.


About the compass...if you go watch Cabin Fever, Richard asks young Locke which of these items are already yours. There are also pictures of the smoke monsters on the wall. I originally thought they were young Locke predicting the future, but I think it makes more ense if Richard had already met older Locke before going to see young Locke.

Maybe he is trying to get him to the island sooner rather than later.

Hanso Amore 01-26-2009 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wwe2222 (Post 2411660)
About the compass...if you go watch Cabin Fever, Richard asks young Locke which of these items are already yours. There are also pictures of the smoke monsters on the wall. I originally thought they were young Locke predicting the future, but I think it makes more ense if Richard had already met older Locke before going to see young Locke.

Maybe he is trying to get him to the island sooner rather than later.

Maybe Locke's consciousness leaves his body, which is why he "dies" and Richard is trying to find him in time. It seems like his adults memories are present in his youth in a sense.

Also...What were the Kids names that were taken from the tail section?

I am joining the wagon of peeps who think Charlotte is the child of a Dharma person, and that Miles is the baby in the beginning of the season, that Professors kid. That is their stake in the big picture. Faraday is involved because of all the time traveling, now we just need to figure out Lapidus's motives, other than being the guy that was suppose to be on the plane.

Hanso Amore 01-26-2009 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedamndest (Post 2410388)
I thought Richard just took the compass out of his pocket and gave it to Locke. Maybe it's just Richard's compass and he knows it will convince his other self that Locke is telling the truth. He shouldn't have had any trouble locating Locke in physical location because when Locke tells him where he is with the bullet in his leg, he will tell him to look by the plane. Locke doesn't know the time, so the question is, has Richard been coming every night to check for a bleeding Locke?

Also, did anyone else not believe Sun when she said she forgave Kate? She will have to return to the island, but if Ben is right in front of her, she would have the opportunity to kill him then. Could that mean that she and Widmore now want to possess the island?

I am pretty convinced that Jack is Jacob.

I think that Sun will betray them for her revenge at some point....I think it will build to that over the season.

Hanso Amore 01-26-2009 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedamndest (Post 2410388)
I thought Richard just took the compass out of his pocket and gave it to Locke. Maybe it's just Richard's compass and he knows it will convince his other self that Locke is telling the truth. He shouldn't have had any trouble locating Locke in physical location because when Locke tells him where he is with the bullet in his leg, he will tell him to look by the plane. Locke doesn't know the time, so the question is, has Richard been coming every night to check for a bleeding Locke?

Also, did anyone else not believe Sun when she said she forgave Kate? She will have to return to the island, but if Ben is right in front of her, she would have the opportunity to kill him then. Could that mean that she and Widmore now want to possess the island?

I am pretty convinced that Jack is Jacob.

Perhaps. Can Jack be a short name for Jacob?

wwe2222 01-26-2009 10:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanso (Post 2411731)
Maybe Locke's consciousness leaves his body, which is why he "dies" and Richard is trying to find him in time. It seems like his adults memories are present in his youth in a sense.

Also...What were the Kids names that were taken from the tail section?

I am joining the wagon of peeps who think Charlotte is the child of a Dharma person, and that Miles is the baby in the beginning of the season, that Professors kid. That is their stake in the big picture. Faraday is involved because of all the time traveling, now we just need to figure out Lapidus's motives, other than being the guy that was suppose to be on the plane.

Not totally sold on Miles being the baby, but cant rule it out. Plus, he is the only one who hasnt really been given a purpose as to why he is there yet. I hope Frank figures into it somehow just because I want to see his character back in some way. After last season ended, I figured he would be the one who transports them back to the island because he'd be the only person they could trust flying them in some fashion back to the island.

Corporate CockSnogger 01-26-2009 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wwe2222 (Post 2408651)
Actually Penny mentions after Desmond wakes up from his dream that he has been off the Island for three years already. That presumably puts him in the same time frame as Ben visiting Hawking.

Ah my bad, guess I missed that.

RP 01-26-2009 05:50 PM

what the hell ever happend to Harper Stanhope?

Hanso Amore 01-26-2009 07:45 PM

Goodwins wife?

thedamndest 01-27-2009 02:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanso (Post 2411736)
Perhaps. Can Jack be a short name for Jacob?

According to google, yes. It would explain why Christian and Claire communicate with Jacob.

wwe2222 01-27-2009 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedamndest (Post 2413099)
According to google, yes. It would explain why Christian and Claire communicate with Jacob.

Could it be that this is why Jack wasnt on Jacob's original list? Because he wouldnt put himself on the list?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:02 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®