Log in

View Full Version : He/She was better when they were in WWE/TNA/WCW/ECW


glanville6
10-28-2010, 10:53 PM
I was thinking of the turnover in the industry throughout all the years. You got a ton of guys and a few divas that have been in 2 or more wrestling companies.

I was always a WWE guy- watched some WCW and ECW, catch bits and pieces now of TNA, but I'm counting on all of you for a good discussion.

Certain names for discussion include:

Jeff Hardy- TNA and WWE
Christian- WWE and TNA
Tazz (as an announcer)- TNA and WWE
RVD- WWE, TNA, ECW
Raven- All 4 major companies
Victoria/Tara- WWE and TNA
Mr. Kennedy/Mr. Anderson- WWE and TNA
Hulk Hogan- WCW and WWE (We can leave TNA out of this)
Ric Flair- WCW and WWE
Rhyno- WWE, TNA, ECW
Goldust/Dustin Rhodes/Black Reign- WWE, WCW, TNA
R-Truth/Ron Killings- WWE and TNA
Booker T.- WWE and TNA and WCW

Feel free to add anyone else. I was just getting the ball rolling.

SaskatchewanChamp
10-28-2010, 10:56 PM
Ric Flair was better in WCW

DLVH84
10-28-2010, 11:12 PM
Sting - WCW and TNA

MoFo
10-28-2010, 11:14 PM
Jeff Hardy- WWE
Christian- TNA
Tazz (as an announcer)- WWE
RVD- ECW
Raven- ECW
Victoria/Tara- WWE
Mr. Kennedy/Mr. Anderson- TNA
Hulk Hogan- WWE
Ric Flair- WCW
Rhyno- ECW
Goldust/Dustin Rhodes/Black Reign- WWE
R-Truth/Ron Killings- TNA
Booker T.- WWE

Ruien
10-28-2010, 11:33 PM
Jeff Hardy- WWE
Christian- TNA
Tazz (as an announcer)- WWE
RVD- ECW
Victoria/Tara- TNA
Mr. Kennedy/Mr. Anderson- TNA
Hulk Hogan- WWF
Ric Flair- WCW
Rhyno- ECW
Goldust/Dustin Rhodes/Black Reign- WWE
R-Truth/Ron Killings- WWE
Booker T.- WCW


Also,

Kurt Angle - TNA (Yes I said TNA)

glanville6
10-28-2010, 11:44 PM
Angle was an interesting one.

Ton of other un named guys out there to discuss everyone!

MoFo
10-29-2010, 11:01 AM
Rey Mysterio - WWE

RiX1024
10-29-2010, 12:18 PM
Jeff Hardy- WWE
Christian- TNA
Tazz (as an announcer)- WWE
RVD- ECW
Raven- ECW
Victoria/Tara- WWE
Mr. Kennedy/Mr. Anderson- TNA
Hulk Hogan- WCW and WWE
Ric Flair- WCW
Rhyno- ECW
Goldust/Dustin Rhodes/Black Reign- WWE
R-Truth/Ron Killings- TNA
Booker T.- WWE and WCW
Kurt Angle - WWE
Rey Mysterio - WWE

Razzamajazz
10-29-2010, 12:24 PM
i actually liked matt morgan in wwe, this is based solely on the only time i saw him there during that royal rumble

The Pope
10-29-2010, 01:38 PM
ECW- Original ECW>WWECW

thedamndest
10-29-2010, 02:07 PM
Jeff Hardy-WWE
Christian- Toss up, leaning WWE's way.
Tazz (as an announcer)- WWE
RVD-ECW
Raven- ECW
Victoria/Tara- Haven't seen her in TNA but I would guess there as it seems she has already had bigger matches than in WWE. She was grossly underused in WWE.
Mr. Kennedy/Mr. Anderson- Haven't seen him in TNA
Hulk Hogan- Toss up. He was a game changer for WCW and WWE. His matches were better in WWE so I'll go with that.
Ric Flair- WCW
Rhyno- WWE. I'm torn on this and ECW but he was honestly better in WWE. Obviously didn't get the same push.
Goldust/Dustin Rhodes/Black Reign- WWE
R-Truth/Ron Killings- TNA
Booker T.- WCW

Jordan
10-29-2010, 03:27 PM
I was thinking of the turnover in the industry throughout all the years. You got a ton of guys and a few divas that have been in 2 or more wrestling companies.

I was always a WWE guy- watched some WCW and ECW, catch bits and pieces now of TNA, but I'm counting on all of you for a good discussion.

Certain names for discussion include:

Jeff Hardy- WWE by far
Christian- TNA from what I can tell
Tazz (as an announcer)- TNA
RVD- ECW for obvious reasons
Raven- I really enjoyed him in WCW, plus I was exposed to WCW more than ECW
Victoria/Tara- WWE / no difference
Mr. Kennedy/Mr. Anderson- No difference that I can tell
Hulk Hogan- WWE for sure, I cant think of one good match he had in WCW.
Ric Flair- Well... WWE... promo's, feuds (including the early 90's) it was his best stuff ever. Maybe the 80's NWA beats it, but not his WCW work.
Rhyno- WWE/ECW he was about equal
Goldust/Dustin Rhodes/Black Reign- WWE
R-Truth/Ron Killings- WWE
Booker T.- He had more great matches in WWE

Feel free to add anyone else. I was just getting the ball rolling.

Brigstocke
10-30-2010, 03:01 AM
When I saw this topic my immediate thought was that The Pope is much better now in TNA than he was in WWE.

There are a bunch of guys at TNA now that I am glad no longer work in the WWE as that is my 'A' promotion. Guys like Rhyno, Jarrett, Booker, Nash, Raven.

But I'd trade a few WWE stars out to TNA to get Angle back and have AJ, Joe, MCMG and Beer Money make the jump.

MrMyc
10-30-2010, 04:40 AM
Jericho-WCW
Nothing wrong with his WWE stuff, but WCW jericho is what got me hooked

Favre4Ever
10-30-2010, 04:42 AM
CM Punk's work in WWE has certainly exceeded his outings in ROH and TNA.

Perry Saturn
10-31-2010, 01:59 AM
Angle-TNA/WWE the guy is just that good. Its damn/true oh its damn/true

Swiss Ultimate
10-31-2010, 02:48 PM
Ric Flair was better in WCW

Ric Flair was better in the NWA.

treyace
11-01-2010, 12:57 AM
Christian - TNA
Ron Killings - TNA
Matt Morgan - TNA
Aj Styles - TNA
CM Punk - WWE
Brian Danielson - ROH
Steve Corino - ROH
Chris Jericho - WWE
Raven - ECW
RVD - as much as i hate too admit it WWE
MCMGs - TNA
Shannon Moore - toss up between TNA and WCW
Jeff Hardy - i think this is the most ive ever liked jeff TNA

Tom Guycott
11-01-2010, 01:59 AM
D'Lo Brown after he jumped to WCW amidst all that speculation that... oh... oh, wait. Nevermind.

steveweiser
11-01-2010, 09:00 AM
Jeff Hardy- made it in WWE but since switching to TNA has had me more interested in him than i have been in years
Christian- Again made it in WWE but when he switched to TNA he bacame one of their biggest names, i prefer the modern day WWE run for Christian though
Tazz (as an announcer)- Fantastic on the mic anywhere IMO
RVD- Had a great run in WWE, TNA not seen so much at the moment but if you want to see the greatest of RVD you need to see the ECW RVD
Raven- I Love this man, anywhere he goes but for the true taste, Raven is all about the hardcore so ECW again has my vote.
Victoria/Tara- TNA all the way, never took notice in WWE but since her TNA arrival iv loved all her work.
Mr. Kennedy/Mr. Anderson- Without a shadow of doubt TNA is Mr. An derson... Anderson
Hulk Hogan- For me Hogan will always be WWE, i remember him growing up and have so many memories of him i can't go for wCw this time. although i loved the nWo in so many ways
Ric Flair- Flair is the man, although i grew up with him WWF i would associate him more wCw so for that reason its wCw sorry.
Rhyno- Wasted in WWE, ECW was home for Rhino but i loved his work in TNA and am glad to see more of him recently. Goldust/Dustin Rhodes/Black Reign- WWE, he was nothing anywhere else for me
R-Truth/Ron Killings- The one guy in wrestling i absolutely cannot stand, words can't describe so im not even going to bother with him
Booker T.- WWE made him look a fool as king booker, TNA wasn't that interested but i did like the wCw Booker.

BodySlam
11-02-2010, 11:25 PM
Hogan - WCW
Hall/razor ramon - WCW
nash/diesel - WCW
Mr. Perfect/curt hennig - WCW
Bret Hart - WWF/E
british bulldog - WWF/E
Booker T - WCW
Raven - WCW
X-pac - WWF/E
Jericho - WWE
Goldberg - WCW
Jeff Hardy - TNA
Jeff Jarrett - WWE (when he was with debra teaming with owen hart)