Rate the Movie day 9: American Beauty

[Dave Youell]

So,

Yesterday's Batman did a 87, making it 3rd overall, we are nearly at a stage when we can have a top 10 that actually means something instead of just fillers.

Today we go for the film that won Kevin Spacey the oscar that year for best actor: American Beauty

GO!

Day 1: Goodfellas 97
Day 2: Fight Club 83
Day 3: Taxi Driver 86
Day 4: Shrek 82
Day 5: American History X 92
Day 6: The Usual Suspects 78
Day 7: The Ring (jap Version) 77
Day 8: Batman 87

Top 7

1. Goodfellas 97
2. American History X 92
3. Batman 87
4. Taxi Driver 86
5. Fight Club 83
6. Shrek 82
7. The Usual Suspects 78
8. The Ring (jap Version) 77

[DaveWadding]

10.

[Zelda]

10.

[Danny Electric]

8

[Dark-Slicer Diago]

8

[SuperSlim]

10 all the way... there is somethin about that movie

[What Would Kevin Do?]

10. Easily one of my favorite movies ever.

[Anybody Thrilla]

10. Es mi favorito.

[PapaGeorgio]

9.9.

[The Mask]

9

pretty awesome. the old homophobe turning out to be a homo always feels like a cop-out to me though.

[Triple A]

On a scale of 1-10 it is an 11. :lol:

[Supreme Olajuwon]

10

[Sephiroth]

10

[John la Rock]

10

great film

[samichna]

I think it is better than what I am going to give it, but I'm giving it a 7, just to weigh the score down a bit.

No movie deserves a 100.

[Anybody Thrilla]

I think it is better than what I am going to give it, but I'm giving it a 7, just to weigh the score down a bit.

No movie deserves a 100.

But if you feel it's better, maybe it DOES deserve it. Ever think of that?

[Boondock Saint]

8

[samichna]

But if you feel it's better, maybe it DOES deserve it. Ever think of that?

It deserves better than 7, but not a 10.

[samichna]

COME ON

[slextremely]

hmm this is hard to judge. This is a wonderful film, I dont wan't to just hand out 10's though, so i'll give it a...
9.8

[Dragon]

9

[Anybody Thrilla]

It deserves better than 7, but not a 10.

Then give it better than a seven. That would both reflect your opinion and drag the score down. But then again, I thought you were supposed to rate the movies and not worry about how well they scored against others. Not trying to sound like a dick, but you know how I mean?

[Boomer]

10

[blueskies]

10

[samichna]

Then give it better than a seven. That would both reflect your opinion and drag the score down. But then again, I thought you were supposed to rate the movies and not worry about how well they scored against others. Not trying to sound like a dick, but you know how I mean?

Yeah I know what you mean. But it gets silly like how all the "good" movies get incredibly overrated.

I am just trying to use my rating vote to voice my opinion about the overall quality of the film. BUT, like I said, I do understand where you're coming from.

[Shaggy]

Sadly to what many people dont think Im gonna have to go with a 6 on this one. I didnt think it was any good. In fact the only reason it gets a 6 is for the fan base behind it and for the stuff that people said about that. There were a few parts in it that I liked but for me it gets a 6.

[diothoir]

9

[RemyRed]

8

Nominate - New Jack City

[#1-norm-fan]

8

[Ogen]

7

[Good News Gertie]

8

[Mister Sinister]

8.5

Because it's the most Beautiful thing in the world...I doubt I can do this. but I nominate..The Cult Favorite and actually informational....Starship Troopers

[BCWWF]

10

[Dave Youell]

8
Sorry, voting closed as of this post.

I was wrestling Yesterday and couldn't close it then, sorry

[Azriel]

Too bad I missed out on this one too. Need to check this forum more often I guess