PDA

View Full Version : Rating The WWE Superstars


Somebody's Gotta Die
05-17-2005, 04:25 PM
This thread is dealing mostly with the quality of the wrestler and his ability to put on memorable matches... In my rankings, I consider wrestling ability more than anything, followed by charisma and finally mic ability... Marketability is an important factor too...

Top 20 Main Event Caliber Superstars:

1. Kurt Angle - best in the business, enough said...

2. Shawn Michaels - delivers constantly, still in his prime, putting over so many people...

3. Eddie Guerrero - heel turn should be great, awesome performer, charisma...

4. Rey Mysterio - can be WWE champ if given the right push...

5. Shelton Benjamin - the next big thing...

6. Chris Benoit - marketability may be a problem at this point, but he's amazing...

7. Rob Van Dam - need to capitalize on his return, he can be awesome and over if pushed and if he can work his own style...

8. Chris Jericho - still great, but has lost a step due to burying over the years...

9. Christian - so high purely due to charisma, has yet to carry awesome matches...

10. Triple H - delivers in big match situations and will go down as one of the best heels ever...

11. The UnderTaker - still delivers and in great shape, hopefully he can put some talent over...

12. Booker T - needs a huge push before retiring... Not the Booker of WCW, but still pretty marketable, in my opinion...

13. Batista - awesome big man, they did a good job with his push...

14. JBL - truly carried SD! last year, awesome charisma, decent ring skills too, actually...

15. Edge - lost a huge step since his injury, but still has a lot of charisma and can still do well as champ in the near future...

16. Randy Orton - still a little sloppy, but damn over and very marketable...

17. John Cena - limited moveset, but his charisma says it all...

18. Carlito - really entertaining and good in the ring too... Deserves the U.S. title for now, if anything...

19. Kane - good big man, his overness has lost a huge step since his unmasking... Not the same marketable character, especially after the runs with Lita and the feud with Snitsky and Viscera...

20. Big Show - still pretty good, not a future WWE champ for me, but someone that can still get a huge pop and put over talent...


Top 10 Tag-Teams:

1. Dudley Boyz - still the best tag-team in WWE, unfortunately...

2. MNM - new and fresh, Melina makes the team what it is, though...

3. Basham Brothers - have gone a long way as a team...

4. Tajiri/Regal or Eugene/Regal - either combo is good in the ring and over...

5. La Resistance - should be Dupree/Grenier... Pretty established team, at least...

6. Hassan & Daivari - they should team these guys, they actually have trememdous potential as a team, in my opinion, as opposed to Hassan on his own...

7. Hurricane & Rosey - this has gotten old and that's when they decide to put the titles on them, what can you do... :-\

8. Simon Dean & Maven - could be good if they get direction and good angles on RAW, however won't amount to anything facing the likes of Venis on HEAT in singles matches

9. Haas & Holly - not a bad team, but they are not pushed and have no momentum, Haas deserves better...

10. Heart Throbs - good to have another team around, but these guys don't really do it for me


Top 10 Divas:

1. Trish Stratus - easy pick...

2. Victoria - only other wrestler, really...

3. Dawn Marie - pretty great, actually...

4. Stacy Kiebler - sexy...

5. Torrie Wilson - sexy...

6. Melina - sexy...

7. Miss Jackie - better than the Diva Search people...

8. Joy - great...

9. Candice - better than Christy, that annoying bitch...

10. Lita - the original ugly dirtbag of wrestling...


Top 10 Cruiserweights:

1. Rey Mysterio - the best, clearly...

2. Chavo Guerrero - awesome...

3. Tajiri - awesome...

4. Paul London - getting really good...

5. Akio - just watch the guy...

6. The Hurricane - deserves better than Rosey...

7. Billy Kidman - lost a huge step since WCW days...

8. Nunzio - I like the guy...

9. Funaki - I like this guy, too...

10. Shannon Moore - :-\ Better than S2H and Spike...

PullMyFinger
05-18-2005, 04:39 PM
Damn, you must've had a lot of time on your hands.

Ruien
05-18-2005, 04:51 PM
Damn, you must've had a lot of time on your hands.

The One
05-18-2005, 05:23 PM
Nice list...have a few disagreements on who was placed where, but I don't feel like making a list of my own as it would take a bit too much time...but nice work though.

Nark Order
05-18-2005, 06:48 PM
We do have a rating system set up here you know... You might wanna check it out.

Nark Order
05-18-2005, 06:50 PM
CHRISTIAN HAS YET TO CARRY AWESOME MATCHES?!?! ARE YOU A FUCKING IDIOT?

Marcyo
05-18-2005, 07:46 PM
CHRISTIAN HAS YET TO CARRY AWESOME MATCHES?!?! ARE YOU A FUCKING IDIOT?
LOL