Top 40 WWE Superstars

[Somebody's Gotta Die]

Criteria for ranking

- Ability to carry a strong match
- Strong overall wrestling skills/style

To a lesser extent

- Promo ability
- Win/loss record

My list:

1. Kurt Angle
2. Shawn Michaels
3. Eddie Guerrero
4. Chris Jericho
5. Chris Benoit
6. Rey Mysterio
7. Shelton Benjamin
8. Rob Van Dam
9. Christian
10. Chavo Guerrero a.k.a. Kerwin White
11. Triple H
12. Randy Orton
13. JBL
14. John Cena
15. Batista
16. Yoshihiro Tajiri
17. Booker T
18. Carlito Carribean Cool
19. The UnderTaker
20. William Regal
21. Val Venis
22. Paul London
23. Super Crazy
24. The Hurricane
25. Rob Conway
26. Ric Flair
27. Juventud Guerrera
28. Nunzio
29. Edge
30. Kane
31. Stevie Richards
32. Psicosis
33. Nick Dinsmore a.k.a. Eugene
34. Matt Hardy
35. Funaki
36. Simon Dean a.k.a. Nova
37. Danny Basham
38. Rene Dupree
39. Doug Basham
40. Hardcore Holly

Meh:
Big Show, Tyson Tomko, Chris Masters, Snitsky, Rosey, Sylvain Grenier, Viscera, Scotty 2 Hotty, Orlando Jordan

MNM, LOD and Heart Throbs are all decent tag-teams, however none really stand out as singles wrestlers...

[Destor]

1. Kurt angle
2. Chris Benoit
3. Eddie Guerrero
4. HHH
5. HBK
6. Shelton Benjamin
7. Ric Flair
8. Christian
9. Carlito Carribian Cool
10.Rob Van Dam (he'd be higher but hes out of smoke, and hes not on the active roster)
40 is asking for way to much

[Jordan]

1. HBK
2. Kurt Angle
3. Chris Jeircho
4. Chris Beboit
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Triple H
7. Christain
8. Shelton Benjamin
9. Edge
10. John Cena

[John la Rock]

My criteria for ranking

1. ability to keep the audience interest
2. wrestling skills/promo skills

Fuck top 40 my top 10 are:

1. Kurt Angle
2. Shawn Michaels
3. Eddie Guerrero
4. Triple H
5. Christian
6. Undertaker
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Jericho
9. John Cena
10. Carlito

[Taker Fan]

Ability to Carry a Good Match/Mic Skills

1) Kurt Angle
2) Eddie Guerrero
3) Shawn Michaels
4) Chris Jericho
5) Chris Benoit
6) Shelton Benjamin
7) Rey Mysterio
8) Triple H
9) Christian
10) Rob Van Dam

[ThruTheWire]

1) Kurt Angle
2) HBK
3) Eddie Guerrero
4) HHH
5) Chris Jericho
6) Chris Benoit
7) Shelton Benjamin
8) RVD
9) Christian
10) Rey

[NoRoolz]

1: Kurt Angle
2: Shawn Michaels
3: Eddie Guerrero
4: Triple H
5: Chris Benoit
6: Chris Jericho
7: Rob Van Dam
8: Rey Mysterio
9: Christian
10: Shelton Benjamin
11: Randy Orton
12: Carlito
13: Undertaker
14: Batista
15: John Cena
16: Kane
17: Ric Flair
18: Booker T
19: Kerwin White
20: Paul London
21: Matt Hardy
22: William Regal
23: Edge
24: Juventud Guerrera
25: Tajiri

That'll do me...

[Nark Order]

1: Kurt Angle
2: Rey Mysterio
3: Eddie Guerrerro
4: HBK
5: Chris Benoit
6: Chris Jericho
7: Randy Orton
8: Christian
9: Booker T
10: Trish Stratus

[Rain Man]

1. Kurt Angle
2. HBK
3. Chris Jericho
4. Shelton Benjamin
5. Randy Orton
6. HHH
7. Eddie Guerrero
8. Christian
9.John Cena
10. Rey

[Somebody's Gotta Die]

Lots of HHH fans, surprisingly...

I don't doubt the man's ability to carry anyone to a decent show, however he has seemingly made everyone's top 10, if not top 5...