Who is the Greatest Band?

[Cuzziebro]

I had an idea the other day, sort of copying something done a while ago. So I have written 84 bands (mostly older rock bands) on paper and put each one into a hat. I am going to randomly draw out two bands, those two bands will face and you decide which band is better, and then the next two bands, etc. I will post all the matches and then wait a week or so, for everyone to have their say. I will then post the results and the next weeks matchups. If you don't undertsand I will give you an example:

Round 1:
U2 vs Air Supply
Pink Floyd vs Backstreet Boys
etc.

Then you will post who you think is better. Whichever band has more votes after the week, will advance to the next round.
Do you guys like the idea, or has it been done too many times before?

[el fregadero]

How about we skip to the final four:
Pink Floyd
Led Zeppelin
The Beatles
Metallica

[road doggy dogg]

blink 182 <3

[The Mask]

how about we skip to the winners

Led Zep

[Cuzziebro]

Well its up to you guys. It was just an idea.

[el fregadero]

Wasn't trying to be mean, but yeah, it's been done before a few times.

If you wanna set it up I'll still vote.

[Cuzziebro]

If it's been done before I might do something new, like have certain styles Rock, Metal, Pop. And see what bands are the best for each music style. Or has that been done before aswell.

[el fregadero]

That has not.

[Cuzziebro]

Well I will start with Metal, propably this week asap. I don't know alot of Metal bands so I need to research a bit, and laos how many bands do you think per style? 20?

[el fregadero]

However many you can fit. 16 is better than 20 because it eliminates better.

[Impact!]

Well I will start with Metal, propably this week asap. I don't know alot of Metal bands so I need to research a bit, and laos how many bands do you think per style? 20?
I can help you with the metal part.

[Cuzziebro]

Cheers bro, I was thinking of talking to you about it tommorow anyways.

[Impact!]

:y:

[weather vane]

I would do 32 metal bands.

AC/DC
Slayer
Motley Crue
Iron Maiden
Helloween
Black Sabbath
Motorhead
Guns and Roses
Judas Priest
Pantera
Metallica
Alice In Chains
Alice Cooper
Kiss
Van Halen
Def Leppard
Dio
Ozzy Osbourne
Skid Row
Twisted Sister
System of a Down
Queensryche
Tool
Dream Theatre
Anthrax
Scorpions
Rage Against The Machine
Faith No More
Twisted Sister
Tesla
Rainbow
Megadeth

Something along those lines. Just pick names out of a hat and do it that way. TPWW's Favorite Metal Band.

[el fregadero]

Don't put Zeppelin in the metal one. Put Megadeth in instead of them.

[weather vane]

Yeah I changed it.

[Skippord]

My head may explode if it comes down to Alice In Chains and MegaDeth/Motley

[el fregadero]

Then you're lucky it's going to come down to Tool and RATM.

[Rammsteinmad]

It's Dream TheatER. :mad:

[Londoner]

My avatar says it all really.Guns n Roses win easily.

[FakeLaser]

Final 4 will probably be Maiden/GNR/Tool/Metallica

[Londoner]

I think you may be right fakerazor.

[Kane Knight]

Queen>j00

[weather vane]

MOTLEY CRUE WILL WIN!

[weather vane]

ok i am doing this rn

taking too long

[FakeLaser]

I would have voted Air Supply over U2, that's how much I hate Bono.

[Skippord]

MOTLEY CRUE WILL WIN!
I agree

[Londoner]

I also hate bono, i hate that band of his as well.Can never get into their music and bono just annoys me.

[Impact!]

The final should come down to Pantera/Motorhead









But no, we have to match them up in the first round :rant: