Paul Burchill is close to returning...

[Mr. Nerfect]

...actually, I'm not sure, but he made an appearance in OVW, and he's been out for a while, so I'm going to suggest that he is. Anyway, what do you think should be done with Burchill?

Burchill as a pirate got him over as rover. However, the WWE will need to realise when to drop the gimmick. I don't fully trust them with that, though.

Am I the only one who wants to see Burchill on RAW? His style would fit in well with the mid-card, and he could have some classics with Shelton Benjamin, etc.

Or they could stick him in a team with Harry Smith.

It's kind of odd, if Regal and Burchill had stayed together, then they would probably both be "Royal Knights" right now, and Burchill and Regal would probably be challenging for the WWE Tag Team Championship, which elevates London & Kendrick, and Burchill would arguably be higher on the card than he was as a pirate. Funny how things work in hindsight.

So yeah, I'm on the fence about Burchill's pirate gimmick returning. Does he need it? Will the WWE fuck it up this time? Should he continue down the face path or turn heel? RAW, SmackDown! or ECW? Would Burchill teaming with either Harry Smith or William Regal (again) be of interest to you?

He's probably the return I'm most interested about (well, he and Benoit). The pirate gimmick makes the most sense now, as it is between Pirates of the Caribbean movies. I say keep it, put him on RAW, and have him feud with Johnny Nitro over the Intercontinental Championship. Have Burchill win it, then go on to feud with Shelton Benjamin.

[Disturbed316]

I'm suprised they haven't had Burchill steal a title and claim it a "pirate booty".

[Chavo Classic]

Turn him heel and include him in Booker's court. Perfect.

[Skippord]

I thought the had already dropped it

[St. Jimmy]

Good, Heat needs a new jobber.

[ClockShot]

Pirates is pretty much wrapping up in theatres. So the gimmick would go out pretty quick.

I agree with Chavo. Stick him in King Booker's court. Then have Burchill and Regal overthrow him or something like that. Get them in the Tag Team scene or have them later feud over the U.S. title somewhere down the line.

[Blitz]

Put him in a stable with Regal and Smith.

[Crippla]

They already said they were dropping the pirate gimmick before Burchill went out so I doubt they'll bring him back with it.

[M-A-G]

Or we can do something, I don't know, completely new and different with him.

[Kane Knight]

I'm suprised they haven't had Burchill steal a title and claim it a "pirate booty".

And bury it.

[M-A-G]

The WWE's doing a fine job of burying its titles by itself, thank you.

[Afterlife]

Pirates is pretty much wrapping up in theatres. So the gimmick would go out pretty quick.

I agree with Chavo. Stick him in King Booker's court. Then have Burchill and Regal overthrow him or something like that. Get them in the Tag Team scene or have them later feud over the U.S. title somewhere down the line.


Pirates 3 comes next summer; it was filmed at the same time as #2. So when he said "between movies", he knew what he was talking about.

As for the pointless heel turn....I don't think King Boring needs anymore random henchmen. Burchill can either keep the gimmick or not -- tho I admittedly adore it -- but reteaming with Regal is about as "gonna happen" as La Resistance getting back together.

I think it would be amazing to have Pirate Paul on RAW. Hardy/Nitro/Benjamin/Carlito.... Looks like an amazing battle for the belt to me.

[The Ravishing One]

Put him in a stable with Regal and Smith.

:y:

[KingofOldSchool]

I want Pirate Paul back, he's more entertaining than "Random stuck up English snob stereotype."

[Kane Knight]

I want Pirate Paul back, he's more entertaining than "Random stuck up English snob stereotype."