Rank them: STP, Classic GNR, VR, New GNR

[The Naitch]

Favorite and/or best:

1. Velvet Revolver (digged out the old album. Really feeling it again)
2. STP (close second)
3. Classic GNR
4. New GNR (Haven't heard much)


(1 being the best of course)

[Blitz]

Classic GNR
STP
Velvet Revolver
New GNR (Just cuz I've heard like 2 songs)

[Requiem]

STP
Velvet Revolver
Classic GNR
New GNR

[ron the dial]

STP
Classic GNR
Velvet Revolver
New GNR (again, due to lack of exposure)

[Kid Robb]

Classic GNR pounds the rest.

[What Would Kevin Do?]

1. Classic GnR
2. STP
3. Velvet revolver
4. new GnR (Due to lack of exposure.)

[MVP]

STP
Velvet Revolver
Classic GNR
New GNR

[Better Than You]

You all come up with some crazy comparisons.

[Zen v.W.o.]

STP
Classic GNR
Velvet Revolver
New GNR (again, due to lack of exposure)

Same.

STP by a long shot though.

[Bad Company]

STP
Classic GNR
Velvet Revolver
New GNR (again, due to lack of exposure)
yeah boy

[Londoner]

Classic GNR
Velvet Revolver(never been a fan of them)
STP(Who?)
New GNR

[Just John]

STP
Classic GNR
Velvet Revolver
New GNR (again, due to lack of exposure)

Exactly

[Londoner]

What is STP short for? I might know the full name.

[Zen v.W.o.]

Stone Temple Pilots, how do you not know? Considering I think it's obvious why these bands are all being ranked among each other.

[Londoner]

Ah yeah i do know them. They the band the singer in VR used to sing for yes?

[Zen v.W.o.]

Ah yeah i do know them. They the band the singer in VR used to sing for yes?


Correct.

[weather vane]

Guns N' Roses
STP
Velvet
Axl and Co.

[The Naitch]

I like TL's custonm title. So I will let his pass on this for asking such a stupid question

[The Naitch]

If you like more glam, then late STP/VR would suit your taste

Earlier STP stuff if you like grunged out Weiland

[The Naitch]

"Get in the ring. Go to the gym, motherfucker, or if you prefer, get a new wig, motherfucker. I think I'll resist the urge to 'stoop' to your level. Oh shit, here it comes, you fat, botox-faced, wig-wearin' fuck! O.K., I feel better now.

"Don't think for a second we don't know where those words came from. Your unoriginal, uncreative little mind — the same mind that had to rely on its bandmates to write melodies and lyrics. Who's the fraud now, bitch?"

[Skippord]

Velvet Revolver
STP
GNR Classic
New GNR

[Rammsteinmad]

Old GNR
Velvet Revolver
STP
New GNR (Only coz I've not heard anything)

[Londoner]

^ Search for the new gnr stuff on youtube if interested, especially the song 'better'. But they're a bit shit overall tbh, the old songs dont sound like they should do.

[ddpBANG]

STP
old GNR
VR
new GNR

[CSL]

<font color=white>Classic GNR
VR
STP
New GNR (not listened to any of it. Came across a download the other day then...didn't download it. I'll get round to it)</font>

[Arnold HamNegger]

1. Classic GNR
(and it's a FAR drop off from here...)

2. VR (Only because of Slash).
3. STP
4. New GNR (Gonna look it up on Youtube).