10 years from now: Top 10 Quarterbacks of all time?

[RP]

I had an idea to do a top 10 list but do it in future tense. 10 years from now.


10 Years from now what would be your top 10 QB's of all time?

[VonErichLives]

without looking at stats off the top of my head.
Also, not in order

P. Manning
Marino
Elway
Montana
Brady
Young
Farve
Baugh
Roethlisberger
Dawson

Honerable Mentions:
Unitis
Moon or Flutie if we count CFL

You could also stat wise make an argument for Bledsoe and Fouts.



Roethlisberger, I went back and forth between him and Brees, figuring one of them might keep it up for another 8-10yrs... and I flipped a coin.

[SammyG]

If Bulger wins some Superbowls, throw him in there.

[CSL]

In no order: Marino, Montana, Favre, Manning, Elway, Moon, Tarkenton, Brady, Palmer, Unitas

[SammyG]

Peyton Manning will be remembered as the greatest quarterback to ever play the game of football.

[RP]

My list would be..

Manning
Brady
Montana
Elway
Marino
Farve
Unitas
Palmer
Brees


I think Palmer and Brees will bump guys like Jim Kelley and Namath out. I dont think Brees is a fluke. I think he'll have a Steve Young like career and bump Young out also.

Also Palmer could be as high as #3 on this list 10 years from now, but it depends on if his whole team isnt jail.

Totally disagree with Rothlisberger. That guy is garbage.

[Nervous Ferret]

CP
CP
CP
CP
CP
CP
CP
CP
CP
CP

[DrA]

That is kinda a complicated question

Ten years from now, I reckon you could put Brady on that list and Manning most likely. Definitely have to have Elway and Montana on it, and I'd imagine Marino would squeeze onto that list as well, as far as the more recent guys go.

Guys like Sammy Baugh, who were the best of their time would earn a spot on my list. Unitas definitely. Staubach without question. Possibly Terry Bradshaw. Maybe Bart Starr.

Obviously I cannot go on telling you about all the older guys since I have a limited number of years on my lifespan. But I can tell you this:

Joe Nameth was the most over-rated quarterback of all time and the only reason why anyone would put his name on such a list is because they can't name anyone else.

And to the person who said Doug Flutie: Go watch soccer or rugby or sea paddling, because his name SHOULD NOT BE 6,000 BILLION LIGHTYEARS FROM THAT LIST.

[DrA]

Also Rectal Pertruder, you do realize that they invented football before 1987 right?

[James Steele]

:lol:

Once again, a Cowboy fan proves his genius.

[FakeLaser]

Dave Brown

[VonErichLives]

And to the person who said Doug Flutie: Go watch soccer or rugby or sea paddling, because his name SHOULD NOT BE 6,000 BILLION LIGHTYEARS FROM THAT LIST.

without looking at stats off the top of my head.

Honerable Mentions:
Unitis
Moon or Flutie if we count CFL



Aperently the DR needs his eyes checked...

If you're counting CFL stats you have to talk about Flutie and Moon being on those lists.

If you don't count CFL stats then of course not...

I'm also one of the most anti-Flutie fans you'll meet, but I have to easily admit if you count CFL stats he's on that list.


Totally disagree with Rothlisberger. That guy is garbage.

Ya know, I wasn't thrilled about putting his name up there... but looking at what he did his first 2 years... I figure if I'm going to put money on a guy with a long career probably ahead of him I'd go with him, I debated putting Brees in that spot... but since Burger already has the ring I went with him and you can make a case for Palmer, I just think 10yrs from now we'll look at him as a good QB but not top 10. It's all semi-guess work with the guys still playing except Manning and Brady.

As for Young getting knocked out... The Rings, the Rushing yds and the passer raitings I think we'll keep him in there.

[RP]

Also Rectal Pertruder, you do realize that they invented football before 1987 right?


I dont get it?

[Stickman]

lol

[VonErichLives]

That is kinda a complicated question

Ten years from now, I reckon you could put Brady on that list and Manning most likely.

Also, right now if Brady and Manning retire today, you would have difficulty making a case for them not to be on that list.

Leading the "career stats" category doesn't always mean you were the best, a lot of times it just means you played a long time.

[Skippord]

Jay Cutler
Jay Cutler
Jay Cutler
Jay Cutler
Jay Cutler
John Elway
John Elway
John Elway
John Elway
John Elway

[D Mac]

Not Jake Plummer, that's for sure.

[Nervous Ferret]

Favre
Brady
Manning
Montana
Elway
Marino
Unitas
Staubach


And the last 2 spots would probably go to Young/Vick/Brees/Cutler/Quinn/Palmer/Roethlisberger/Bulger/Alex Smith/McNabb/Rivers/Leinart/Russell?/Romo?/Kellen Clemens?/E Manning??

Impossible to tell now but I would say it is likely that 2 of those guys from that list could be considered top 10 of all time in 10 years

[RP]

Oh man. Ferret really got me. I didnt think about Vince Young. Every since the year that Texas won the National title. Even before the title game, i though Young was gunna be amazing and i still think that. Man i dont even know. Vince Young has top 5 possibilty. I think he can be amazing in 3 years or so.

[RP]

Kellen Clemens......lol.

[Nervous Ferret]

I put Kellen Clemens in not because I think he will even play a down in the NFL, but I was more or less eluding to the fact that it is impossible to tell now.

[RP]

its not impossible to make an educated guess. And saying Clemens could be top 10 of all time is retarded.

[Nervous Ferret]

lol clearly a joke bro, I already said I don't think he will ever play a (competitve) down in the NFL

[Triple A]

Neil O'Donnell

[RP]

Andre Dawson

[mrslackalack]

In no order

Manning
Montana
Unitas
Elway
Favre
Marino
Palmer
Brady
Staubach
Namath

[YOUR Hero]

there's a 15 year old that in 10 years from now is going to change that list.

[ClockShot]

In any random order.

John Elway
Troy Aikman
Joe Montana
Joe Namath
Tom Brady
Dan Marino
Peyton Manning
Brett Farve
Ben Roethlisberger (If he doesn't jump on a motorcycle ever again.)
Johnny Unitas

Honorable mentions go to Terry Bradshaw, Drew Bledsoe, Doug Flutie, Drew Brees, Kordell Stewart, Warren Moon, Carson Palmer

[RP]

there's a 15 year old that in 10 years from now is going to change that list.


No they wouldnt cause we're talking about GOAT and its not realistic to think that a 25 year old rookie or 2nd year player could be considered GOAT.

[el fregadero]

lol Kordell Stewart

[VonErichLives]

Honorable mentions go to Kordell Stewart

That was a joke right?

If you're looking for a running QB I'd take Cunningham over Stewart any day of the week and Cunningham isn't making that list.

[mrslackalack]

Yeah, I agree Cunnigham and Moon were much better QBs than Kordell

[Gonzo]

:lol:

Once again, a Cowboy fan proves his genius.

I didn't see you form a list, why don't you shed some of your exuberating genius?

I think Peyton is definitely on that list, as I think most people would agree.

I'm on my way out the door so I can't offer a full list. :o

[Kris P Lettus]

Archie Manning
Jeff Blake
Bobby Hebert
Drew Brees
Aarron Brooks
Jim Everett
John Fourcade
Billy Joe Hobert
Kenny Stabler
Kerry Collins

Honorable Mention: Jake "The Cajun Snake" Delhomme

:shifty:

[Gonzo]

For a second all I saw was Kerry Collins and was like what...the...fuck?

Then I realized.

[Kris P Lettus]

:(

[VonErichLives]

For a second all I saw was Kerry Collins and was like what...the...fuck?

Then I realized.

that was my reaction to jeff blake... then I saw Hebert and started laughing...

[Skippord]

Rex Grossman

[Supreme Olajuwon]

What has Roethlisberger done to show that he will be one of the greatest QBs ever? Last time I checked he's what Rex Grossman was last year except he didn't have to throw as much.

[VonErichLives]

What has Roethlisberger done to show that he will be one of the greatest QBs ever? Last time I checked he's what Rex Grossman was last year except he didn't have to throw as much.

first 2 seasons had decent stats, but not a lot of yards. last year a lot more throwing but everything else went down.

I just wanted to throw someone in my top 10 that was a "future pick" and adding the fact he has a ring already, I gambled on him over Palmer and Brees.

[McLegend]

Here is Ben Roethlisberger's numbers

| Passing | Rushing |
+----------+-----+---------------------------------------+-----------------+
| Year TM | G | Comp Att PCT YD Y/A TD INT | Att Yards TD |
+----------+-----+---------------------------------------+-----------------+
| 2004 pit | 14 | 196 295 66.4 2621 8.9 17 11 | 56 144 1 |
| 2005 pit | 13 | 168 268 62.7 2385 8.9 17 9 | 31 69 3 |
| 2006 pit | 15 | 280 469 59.7 3513 7.5 18 23 | 32 98 2 |
+----------+-----+---------------------------------------+-----------------+
| TOTAL | 42 | 644 1032 62.4 8519 8.3 52 43 | 119 311 6


Here is Carson Palmer's numbers

+---------------------------------------+-----------------+
| Passing | Rushing |
+----------+-----+---------------------------------------+-----------------+
| Year TM | G | Comp Att PCT YD Y/A TD INT | Att Yards TD |
+----------+-----+---------------------------------------+-----------------+
| 2004 cin | 14 | 263 432 60.9 2897 6.7 18 18 | 18 47 1 |
| 2005 cin | 16 | 345 509 67.8 3836 7.5 32 12 | 34 41 1 |
| 2006 cin | 16 | 324 520 62.3 4035 7.8 28 13 | 26 37 0 |
+----------+-----+---------------------------------------+-----------------+
| TOTAL | 46 | 932 1461 63.8 10768 7.4 78 43 | 78 125 2 |


How can you possibly gamble on Roethlisberger over Palmer?

[Kris P Lettus]

Or Brees??

[Shisen Kopf]

Archie Manning
Jeff Blake
Bobby Hebert
Drew Brees
Aarron Brooks
Jim Everett
John Fourcade
Billy Joe Hobert
Kenny Stabler
Kerry Collins

Honorable Mention: Jake "The Cajun Snake" Delhomme

:shifty:

come on man, the real list is as follows

Charlie Batch
Rodney Peete
Andre Ware
Erik Kramer
Scott Mitchell
Joey Harrington
Mike McMahon
Jon Kitna
Stoney Case
Eric Hipple

[Vastardikai]

Elway
Montana
S. Young
Unitas
P. Manning (He seems to be the most engaged QB in the game, as far as play calling goes. I also see him being a great coach)
Marino (It's a shame his legacy is more about what he DIDN'T accomplish)
Staubach
Favre
Brady
I Wouldn't Doubt Vince Young being here in a few years.

[MTH15]

there's a 15 year old that in 10 years from now is going to change that list.
:yes:

Manning
Brady
Marino
Montana
Young
Elway
Tarkenson
Farve
Moon
MTH

[Mercury Bullet]

Two Words: Jim Drunkenmiller :y:














:shifty:

[Mercury Bullet]

Okay f'reals:

(No particular order)

Peyton Manning
Joe Montana
Tom Brady
Johnny Unitas
Bret Favre
John Elway
Dan Marino
Steve Young
Warren Moon
Joe Namath

[Mercury Bullet]

Oh, and this one is serious. If Trent Dilfer would have started his career on a better team we'd be talking about him right now. Seriously, the Bucs in that era where the worst team ever assembled and if he would have got his career off to a good start, I think he would be up there. Not a phenomenal athlete but a smart player and proven winner even without great players around him. Everybody needs SOME help though and that Bucs team was god-awful.

[Nervous Ferret]

I think we need to reconsider our position on Kellen Clemens. In 10 years, he will def be at least in the top 12 QBs of all time