Is Heath ledger going to be a better Joker than Jack?

[Renaissance man]

He could really. Heath's final great curtain call, its poetic.

[Stickman]

I dunno man, Jack is amazing.

[Renaissance man]

I know dude.

[Stickman]

I'm not going to watch the movie analysing if Ledger was better than Jack but after I may think back an critique it.

[Renaissance man]

maybe it wouldn't be fair to the memory of Ledger to compare him to an all time cinema great such as Jack

[RP]

I dunno, but if the charachter lives up to the trailer's i've seen. He should get an Oscar. Cause he looks fantastic in it. Really dark and really pyscho. But we'll have to see the movie.

[RP]

I think this Batman movie is gunna break a ton of records when it opens too.

[wwe2222]

not that i am worried much about it, but yes i think he is.

[Champion of Europa]

I never really liked Jack's Joker. It's just Jack Nicholson goofing around. I never thought, "Hey, that's The Joker." I thought, "That's Jack Nicholson with a lot of makeup."

Heath Ledger appears to have lost himself in the role.

[Kane Knight]

Ledger should be epic.

[Renaissance man]

I never really liked Jack's Joker. It's just Jack Nicholson goofing around. I never thought, "Hey, that's The Joker." I thought, "That's Jack Nicholson with a lot of makeup."

Heath Ledger appears to have lost himself in the role.

he went too far with his creation :(

[Downunder]

I never really liked Jack's Joker. It's just Jack Nicholson goofing around. I never thought, "Hey, that's The Joker." I thought, "That's Jack Nicholson with a lot of makeup."

Heath Ledger appears to have lost himself in the role.

I agree 100%

[U-Warrior]

I think the versions of the Joker they are playing, are so different that it becomes unfair to compare them. It really comes down to personal preferance, as opposed to one being definitivly better than the other.

That said, I like the grittier, realistic Nolan style, rather than the goth-cartoonish style of burton, so I'll probably like ledger's version better.

[Heros Welcome]

I think the versions of the Joker they are playing, are so different that it becomes unfair to compare them. It really comes down to personal preferance, as opposed to one being definitivly better than the other.

That said, I like the grittier, realistic Nolan style, rather than the goth-cartoonish style of burton, so I'll probably like ledger's version better.

I agree 100%. You hit the nail right on the head

[Lock Jaw]

I never really liked Jack's Joker. It's just Jack Nicholson goofing around. I never thought, "Hey, that's The Joker." I thought, "That's Jack Nicholson with a lot of makeup."

Heath Ledger appears to have lost himself in the role.

I too agree with this. Jack gave a good performance, and I love him in that movie, but I don't find the Joker to be as good a Joker representation as Ledger promises to have.

Which goes down to what U-Warrior is saying... the two different styles of the films... and I think that Nolan's style is going to do more to truly capture the essence of The Joker.

[ct2k]

How the fuck can anyone know until they've seen the new film you stupid fat idiot?

[Blue Demon]

Was that really necessary ct2k?

[ct2k]

Entirely, Renaissance man is a stupid cuntbollocks

[Fox]

http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a165/miss_whisky/HeathLedgerJackNicholsonJoker.jpg

We're dealing with oil and vinegar here. Two different things, equally great in their own way.

Nothing I can say that hasn't been said before. Just that I can't wait for TDK.

[Confused]

I'm loving Ledgers shirt there! Very nice.

[slextremely]

What i have seen from Heath so far, blows anything Nicholson did out of the water.

[ct2k]

Ledger does look fucking immense from the trailers, can't fucking wait

[RP]

Has it been confirmed that Harvey Dent will actually be Two Face in this because if you watch the new trailer and pause it at 2:03 you can see him holding the gun and you can see the outline makeup of the other side of his face.

[El Fangel]

Here is what I think.

Jacks Joker does not fit into this new Batman movie, the same way Ledgers would not fit into the old one.

[El Fangel]

Has it been confirmed that Harvey Dent will actually be Two Face in this because if you watch the new trailer and pause it at 2:03 you can see him holding the gun and you can see the outline makeup of the other side of his face.

Link me up Mr. Danger.

[RP]

<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/mVi-jDROaLU&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/mVi-jDROaLU&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

[El Fangel]

:drool:

I change my view, yes Ledger is better.

[Vastardikai]

Cesar Romero gets no respect...

[RP]

Hey fuck Cesar Romero

[Zen v.W.o.]

Has it been confirmed that Harvey Dent will actually be Two Face in this because if you watch the new trailer and pause it at 2:03 you can see him holding the gun and you can see the outline makeup of the other side of his face.

http://www.aintitcool.com/images2007/DentBurn.jpg

As for the comparisons, two totally different styles fit for two totally different styles of movies. Jack was incredible in his performance.

[McLegend]

Zen pulls an RP.

[El Fangel]

Omfg, THAT is Two-Face?

[Vastardikai]

Hey fuck Cesar Romero

http://mantequillaconazucar.files.wordpress.com/2007/12/cesar_romero_joker.gif

[RP]

http://www.aintitcool.com/images2007/DentBurn.jpg

As for the comparisons, two totally different styles fit for two totally different styles of movies. Jack was incredible in his performance.

I dont know about that

It looks cool. I just dont know about that though. Its not exactly what i remember Two Face being like. But it looks good.

[Blue Demon]

AFAIK he becomes two-face somewhere near the end of the movie too.

[Loose Cannon]

what COE and Kane Knight said. I think we're in for an epic performance

[El Fangel]

I agree, and Im already waiting for a third one, they have to have a third one.

[Kalyx triaD]

Would have been nice to put that Two-Face pic under a link.

Thanks for that.

[ron the dial]

from what i've seen i'm leaning towards ledger as the performance that i'll enjoy more. but that's like saying i like mint chocolate chip ice cream better than cookie dough ice cream.

[Zen v.W.o.]

Would have been nice to put that Two-Face pic under a link.

Thanks for that.

You're welcome.