Who deserves to win the Royal Rumble more Kane or Big Show?

[Rollermacka]

Simple question, who do you think should win the Rumble the Big Show or Kane? They have always been my "other picks" because there size. Big Show has been in the final four several times and Kane has the record for both most eliminations and fastest elimination. So which one do you think deserves to win the Royal Rumble more?

[Xero]

Honestly, I think Show would draw better, and that's why I'd take him over Kane.

[Mr. Nerfect]

I'm not going to vote, because it's hard to qualify "deserves." I think both guys should have had more success than they have in the WWE. As Xero said, Big Show would probably be the better draw, but I just cannot ignore my heart pulling for Kane.

Either way, if one of them won it, it should be on a monster tear.

[HBPunk]

didnt vote, if either man won id be devastated that my favourite PPV had raped me

[Supreme Olajuwon]

be a pretty hilarious rape though

[Nicky Fives]

Unless kane can get into a little better shape, my vote goes to Show

[Robodiv]

Disco Inferno or Alex Wright.

[HBPunk]

Disco Inferno or Alex Wright.

YES! :yes:

[Indifferent Clox]

I want disco inferno to comeback so bad

[screech]

Can't go against The Big Red Machine.

[The Gold Standard]

Kane. He never gets a title shot anymore.

[screech]

I love both guys and agree with Noid that they both should have had more success. Hard to pick (that's a lie, you all knew I'd pick Kane), but with either guy it could be a good build to WM.

Kane has the distinction of being World Champion for 24 hours, one he would surely want to put behind him. He could rip through everyone to get to the [WWE] champion and truly become a monster again en route to a decent reign with the belt. This would probably require a legit heel turn (it would probably be better to sell him as monstrous), but that can be done relatively easily.

Big Show, as he said before Bragging Rights, is all about advancing his career. His partnership with Jericho can be used as a stepping stone, citing their dominance since they became a team. Also, he can become the only man to hold WCW, ECW, WWE and WHC gold.

None of that will probably happen, but it would be nice. There hasn't been a really dominant (Taker doesn't count) champion in a while.

[XCaliber]

Kane already has the destinction of having the most eliminations but i'd still rather have him win a Rumble and it would be cool if he destroyed his own record.

[Swiss Ultimate]

write-in: CM Punk. The guy has been extremely entertaining both in and out of the ring. He deserves to main-event Wrestlemania.

[Lock Jaw]

Big Show for sure. If Kane won in 2010, it would just be a joke.

Big Show has remained a credible monster though. Just recently he fought pretty much the entire Raw Roster and it took all of them to bring him down.

[The Jayman]

Kane

[thedamndest]

It depends what you mean by deserve. Big Show would be a better draw. Kane stuck with the company through loads of terrible gimmicks and storylines. Neither man should actually win it though.

[DAMN iNATOR]

Kane.

[GD]

ZOMG! CHUCK NORRIS! AAAAAAAAAAH... :eeks:

[Juan]

ZOMG! CHUCK NORRIS! AAAAAAAAAAH... :eeks:

:?:

[Rammsteinmad]

Technically they both deserve it, but from a business standpoint I don't think it'd be any good.

[Jordan]

Big Show for sure, Kane can't draw and Big Show is the new Andre, if they booked him right after the Rumble he could draw against any face champion. Although we have seen Cena/Show way too many times for that to be a main event at Wrestlemania.

[DrA]

The only people who deserve to win the Royal Rumble are the ones who go out there and win it.

[Dante69]

The Brooklyn Brawler:)

[screech]

Write-in: Drew Carey.

He would totally draw and he has a history with Kane.

[screech]

:shifty:

[TGR]

Unless kane can get into a little better shape, my vote goes to Show


The irony of this statement burns.