Dave Mustaine or James Hetfield.

[D Mac]

Do it.

[The Mask]

i like the way dave mustaine sings like he's constipated and trying with all his might to poo.

[Brujesino]

dave

[LuigiD]

I like both. Hard to pick one..too bad Mustaine does not do drugs anymore..the last couple of Deth' albums have sucked ass.

[Sixx]

It's always hard to vote for a ginger, but I see no other option here.

[DaveWadding]

Daves Unite!

[Sixx]

Fuck, my name is the Polish version of James.

[The Franchise]

Davey boy.

[D Mac]

Blasphemy

[Jeritron]

Why would you post the poll if you are only going to tolerate one response?

[StingerSplash4Lyf]

i used to like metalicca but damn they sold out huh. their not real metal in my mind

[blake639raw]

Mustaine.

[Skippord]

Dave Mustaine

as Megadeth is much better than Metallica

[D Mac]

Incorrect Skippord but thanks for playing. We have some lovely parting gifts for you.

Not really, just a swift kick in the ass. :mad:

[Vastardikai]

Joey Belladona. :shifty:

[St. Jimmy]

No.

[ron the dial]

hetfield has a tiny penis and tinier talent

[D Mac]

Fuck you Faggot X :foc:

[ron the dial]

oh get over it tiny penis lover

[Indifferent Clox]

hahahahahahahhahahaha

[D Mac]

HETFIELD IS GOD

[D Mac]

This is bullshit.

TPWW you disappoint me. :(

[Sixx]

Not much of a god if he got owned by chickenpox.

[Kane Knight]

Mustaine, but not because I like him so much as I dislike him less. Now, if you asked me to pick between Kurt Kermit and Mustane, or any of the other fifty guitarists for Megadeth over the years, it'd be a much harder choice.

[Rammsteinmad]

Huge fan of both bands, but easily James Hetfield.

Dave Mustaine is better on guitar in my opinion, but James mostly focuses on rhythm. Both are pretty tight players though. However, in my opinion James is a much better vocalist and frontman. He is much better on the mic and has the all-round 'rock star' feel about him.

My main reason though, is simply because Dave Mustaine is the Bret Hart of heavy metal. He's a whiney bitch who has never been able to get over something as retarded as being kicked out of a band. On 'Some Kind of Monster' Dave's whinging to Lars about 'Do you have any idea what it was like?' etc etc, when for fucks sake there are MILLIONS of bands who would kill for quarter of the success Megadeth has had.

Also, I've met Dave Mustaine and he is one miserable fucker.

Both solid musicians, but definitely like James Hetfield more.

[Rammsteinmad]

Also, Hetfield just generally seems like one cool fucking dude! :cool:

[Sixx]

. He is much better on the mic and has the all-round 'rock star' feel about him.


http://www.portlandmercury.com/images/blogimages/2008/09/16/r_1221585251_hetfield.jpg

ROCK N ROLL!

[The Mask]

Fuck, my name is the Polish version of James.

what, no it isn't :'(

[Sixx]

what, no it isn't :'(

Yeah, it is. That's how you translate it. Not sure why, but it stands for both James and Jacob.

[El Vaquero de Infierno]

http://www.portlandmercury.com/images/blogimages/2008/09/16/r_1221585251_hetfield.jpg

ROCK N ROLL!

:rofl::rofl::rofl:

That is priceless.

[Stickman]

Only a rockstar could buy something at an Armani store while wearing flip flops.

[D Mac]

Huge fan of both bands, but easily James Hetfield.

Dave Mustaine is better on guitar in my opinion, but James mostly focuses on rhythm. Both are pretty tight players though. However, in my opinion James is a much better vocalist and frontman. He is much better on the mic and has the all-round 'rock star' feel about him.

My main reason though, is simply because Dave Mustaine is the Bret Hart of heavy metal. He's a whiney bitch who has never been able to get over something as retarded as being kicked out of a band. On 'Some Kind of Monster' Dave's whinging to Lars about 'Do you have any idea what it was like?' etc etc, when for fucks sake there are MILLIONS of bands who would kill for quarter of the success Megadeth has had.

Also, I've met Dave Mustaine and he is one miserable fucker.

Both solid musicians, but definitely like James Hetfield more.

:y:

[blake639raw]

http://www.portlandmercury.com/images/blogimages/2008/09/16/r_1221585251_hetfield.jpg

ROCK N ROLL! Haha, I love this pic.

[blake639raw]

Damn Dieselmac, do you have a mancrush on Hetfield or something?

[Sixx]

He dreams of fucking Hetfield in his chickenpox spots.

[Kalyx triaD]

I love how bands who finally get the recognition and money they work for, then start taking risks with different styles, they "sold out". That line is so fucking tired.

[Kalyx triaD]

Give me Megadeth tracks.

[Vastardikai]

I stand by Joey Belladonna as the better vocalist.

As far as between James and Dave, they both have their strengths and weaknesses. I enjoy both them for different reasons.

I love how bands who finally get the recognition and money they work for, then start taking risks with different styles, they "sold out". That line is so fucking tired.

I think Load and Reload would be considered good albums if they were put out by any band NOT named Metallica. Same with Risk and Megadeth.

I think we can all agree that St. Anger is the musical equivalent of James taking a great big shit in a pot and Lars banging on it.

[Kalyx triaD]

Yeah, St. Anger was weird - and I won't try to be apologetic citing their personal issues at the time of that recording. But I'm talking about jackass critics and like to call "sell out" at the drop of a dime.

[D Mac]

I think Load and Reload would be considered good albums if they were put out by any band NOT named Metallica. Same with Risk and Megadeth.



Load was an EXCELLENT album from top to bottom. Reload was good but Load is great. Just because they cut their hair...

[Rammsteinmad]

I've been listening to Load and Reload quite a lot lately so I could review them on a website. Both albums got 4/5 from me. Seriously.

Given enough listens the songs have grown on me and their still pretty fucking heavy and crunchy. Especially Reload. Songs like 'Attitude' and 'Bad Seed' are really ballsy and rockin', but nobody really seems to know about them coz their like, lesser songs on the 'shit album' or summit.

People should see past Load and Reloads reputations as 'bad albums' and really give them a few spins. The material is amazing.

[Rammsteinmad]

Except for 'Low Man's Lyric' on Reload. That song is kinda tacky...

[The Mask]

st anger was a sellout album. "raw" sound as was the trend at the time, along with no solos. absolutely atrocious.

[Kalyx triaD]

Kirk Hammit was pretty vocal about it.

[Skippord]

Dave Mustaine would roundhouse kick James Hetfield and probably kill him

[bigdaddysuperfreak]

Bruce Dickinson.

[IC Champion]

Both suck very very much.

[Arashi Kage]

I've always enjoyed Dave and Megadeth far more than Metallica.

I also support the choice of Belladonna over both Mustaine and Hetfield. :y:

[D Mac]

Dave Mustaine would roundhouse kick James Hetfield and probably kill him

I don't fucking think so son. James would break Dave's little fucking faggot neck.

[Sixx]

True, Anthrax is far better than both Metallica and Megadeth.

[D Mac]

lol no

[D Mac]

Yeah I know some of you voted against James just to annoy me. We all know who the greatest is.

[Vastardikai]

lol no

You do know Anthrax did play a HUGE part in Metallica getting established on the east coast, right? (I believe they even gave the boys a place to stay)

[D Mac]

How nice of them. Then they got bypassed.

[Vastardikai]

To be fair, my personal preference of Anthrax over Metallica is just that: a personal preference.

I do like the early stuff of Metallica's, and I consider it some of the best stuff ever. I also like some Exodus, but I understand why they're ranked #5 in the big 5 thrash bands. Anthrax's role as #4 is as much bad luck as anything else.

[Kalyx triaD]

What does that have to do with who's better? I don't think that factors, though I'm sure Metallica appreciated the help.

[Vastardikai]

What does that have to do with who's better? I don't think that factors, though I'm sure Metallica appreciated the help.

If it came across like that, it wasn't my intention. I misread D-Mac's thing with Anthrax as him being like Anthrax had no merit what-so-ever.

Again, go up to my point where it's a Personal Preference. I just personally like Anthrax better.

[Kalyx triaD]

Is Anthrax in the vein of Metallica and Megadeth's style?

[BigDaddyCool]

Yes they are.

[Vastardikai]

The Big 4 (I often include Exodus, Kirk Hammett's old band, as being part of the Big 5) American Thrash Bands are Metallica, Megadeth, Slayer, and Anthrax.

And they're linked, for the most part. Kirk of Metallica is formerly of Exodus. Of course Dave Mustaine is ex-Metallica, but he started Megadeth with Slayer's Kerry King, IIRC. And there's the bit of Anthrax helping out 'tallica get established on the east coast.

[BigDaddyCool]

Then there is Pantera.

[Sixx]

R.I.P.

[Skippord]

I made a thread about thrash a few years ago when I was incredibly into Megadeth and Slayer

that was a nice time

[Juan]

Yeah I know some of you voted against James just to annoy me. We all know who the greatest is.

What the hell was the point of this poll/thread then?

[D Mac]

Guess I'm just a glutton for punishment.

[D Mac]

Metallica wins.

Metallica always wins.

Is there no one on this planet to even challenge them?

[Spaff]

Metallica wins.

Metallica always wins.

Is there no one on this planet to even challenge them?

your such a spa

[The Pope]

Tied at 19-19 for now

[D Mac]

LOL

[Rammsteinmad]

20-19 to Hetfield.

Diesal Mac can sleep well tonight.

[Juan]

Fuck, I accidentally voted for Hetfield

[D Mac]

Haha

[Blue Demon]

Mustaine

[Kane Knight]

Damn Dieselmac, do you have a mancrush on Hetfield or something?

I think he wants science to sufficiently advance so he could carry Hatfield's babies.

I love how bands who finally get the recognition and money they work for, then start taking risks with different styles, they "sold out". That line is so fucking tired.

You do understand that "sold out" in that definition wouldn't apply to Metallica, right? They "sold out" in the sense most people use: That they made more commercially viable, safer records. Lyrically, perhaps not, but they opted for more mainstream records.

They did the opposite of taking risks. They turned their albums into, essentially, "flavor of the week" deals.

But hey, it's not a bad thing, either. It just happens that Metallica was kind of a one-trick pony to begin with, and attempting to alter their style revealed a lot more flaws. And virgins everywhere had one less band to wangst to.

[Kalyx triaD]

They cut their hair, get over it.

[D Mac]

Dammit Sascha. :mad:

[D Mac]

Tied again. :lol:

[Brujesino]

tie?


this is a outrage dave is ten times better then james

TEN!!!:mad:

[D Mac]

WOOOOOOOO James wins!

[Sixx]

I bet you fucking hacked this fucking poll, and fucking voted 21 times for that fucking fuck Hetfield, you fucking fuck.

[D Mac]

Who's the fucker who tied it back up. Lynch that asshole. :mad:

[D Mac]

What a battle!

[asphyXy]

Dave Mustaine wrote all of Metallica's good songs.

[Sixx]

Diesel Mac, looks like you failed with your poll.

[Brujesino]

i like the way things are looking right now

[D Mac]

Whatever. This proves nothing other then the fact that you people are jealous of the greatest band in the world.

[Arashi Kage]

Whatever. This proves nothing other then the fact that you people are jealous of the greatest band in the world.

You're talking about Judas Priest, right? :shifty: :y:

[D Mac]

James already won before someone made 3 socks just to annoy me so...

The winner and STILL world frontman champion, JAMES HETFIELD!


End of thread.

[ron the dial]

not the end

[D Mac]

Yes it is.

[Sixx]

This thread is horrible.

[Sixx]

Actually no, only the posts by Diesel Mac.

[D Mac]

SEEK AND DESTROY :mad:

[ron the dial]

Rust In Piece

[D Mac]

At least I speak up and stick to my guns. Not like some of the other pussys around here. :mad:

[ron the dial]

please elaborate on that point, Diesel Mac.

[Sixx]

Here's my stand:

Metallica Blows.

[Vastardikai]

Talking to D-Mac is like Clapping with One hand. :shifty:

*for the record I voted for Jaymz*

[D Mac]

Here's my stand:

I blow young guys.

[Rammsteinmad]

I can't believe this thread has reached 100 replies.

[Big Fat Mike]

Diesel Mac ,

I like Metallica too, but you're acting like a huge fag and a 7 year old. Please Grow up.

-BFM

[D Mac]

No

[Big Fat Mike]

PLEASSSSEEEEEEEE

[Sixx]

I'm pretty sure that even if I liked Metallica, I would hate it by now.

[D Mac]

Fine, you win blah blah blah I will go on listening to the great ones and not look back.

I'm out.

[Brujesino]

i knew people werent dumb enough to vote james over dave

good job guys:y:

[Malfeitor]

I voted Mustaine because I think he's a better musician.

And for the record...

Slayer >>> Metallica

[D Mac]

All I have left to say is that I'm really disappointed in you TPWW. :(

[ct2k]

Mustaine, he stayed truer to his 'thrash roots' and didn't sell out (as much) as Hetfield did.

Also he did loads of drugs, pretty sure hetfield didn't, not very rock and/or roll.

[Rammsteinmad]

Ah, but Hetfield went into rehab for alcoholism and has since found a happier meaning in life.

Mustaine 'found God', has an 18 year old son and yet is still a miserable bitch who whinges and bitches about the past. Great role model for his children. :y:

For the record, I'm a fan of both, I'm not Anti-Dave or anything, just saying really...

[Rammsteinmad]

All I have left to say is that I'm really disappointed in you TPWW. :(

I got your back DM. :wave:

[Heros Welcome]

I don't know if this is just Diesel Mac hate or if everyone is serious. Come on now! Hetfield is the right choice. METALLICA!!

[D Mac]

They all like to gang up on me because they think it's funny. :(

[Malfeitor]

It's not like I'm anti-Metallica or anything. As a matter of fact, Metallica's first four albums are better than anything Megadeth has ever done. But from my point of view as a musician, I just think Mustaine has more depth in his playing.

Don't hate me, Diesel Mac. :heart:

[Big Fat Mike]

Come on, dmac, please stop being a whiny cunt. You always have the Royals! Or ..um... do you have a hockey team in K.C.? No bastkeball team...how about trying to reorganize the Monarchs of the Negro League? There are more important things than trying to decide which aging singer/guitar player is better. Take having sex, for example. Nobody loses when sex is had - unless someone had Aids. Then you may have a problem. I suggest meeting a nice girl down at your local Church ( no baptist churches) and NOT talking to her about metallica. Or maybe you could try meeting a nice teenager? Have you talked to Roxer about the benefits of touching underage people?

I'm just saying, I'm sure you have better ways to spend your time. I'll leave it at this; what are you going to do when Metallica is no more? They play the type of music that just can't be played into life's final years. They're all pushing 50, and thats pretty old for a metal act. Don't try to argue that Ozzy or Lemmy are in their sixties and still rockin, because Lemmy has pure alchohol running though his veins and Ozzy doesn't exactly "tour" anymore. I say you appreciate both bands for what they are while it lasts, and stop trying to decide who you would enjoy blowing more.

[D Mac]

Metallica is forever.

[bigdaddysuperfreak]

Listening to Metallicas version of "Tuesdays Gone" automatically strips James of any metal creditability he may have had.

[Kalyx triaD]

Funny how singular examples accomplish this amid volumes of material. Good show.

[bigdaddysuperfreak]

Well you can include "The Unforgiven", "Until it Sleeps", "Hero of the Day", and im sure there are others I cant remember.

[Kalyx triaD]

Still on the shallow end of the pool there. But enjoy... disliking things, I guess.

[bigdaddysuperfreak]

So you are telling me that making slow whiney songs doesnt discredit you for being a metal band? Wait why am I arguing with the guy who fervently watches power rangers about the values of metal?

[Kalyx triaD]

So you are telling me that making slow whiney songs doesnt discredit you for being a metal band?

Yes. By your attempted logic merely creating certain material makes you a certain genre band... but Gwen Stefani will never be a hip hopper.

Wait why am I arguing with the guy who fervently watches power rangers about the values of metal?

What does this even mean? :lol:

[Sixx]

Yes. By your attempted logic merely creating certain material makes you a certain genre band... but Gwen Stefani will never be a hip hopper.



Actually creating certain material may exclude you from a certain genre.

[Kalyx triaD]

Fine.

[D Mac]

Well you can include "The Unforgiven", "Until it Sleeps", "Hero of the Day", and im sure there are others I cant remember.

:nono:

[Kane Knight]

They cut their hair, get over it.

LOL.

I love the fact that you're too retarded to even understand what "sold out" means, lecture on a strawman premise, and that's your best comeback.

Even Mac could see through that one, and he's got Hetfield's cock in his eye.

[Kane Knight]

Ah, but Hetfield went into rehab for alcoholism and has since found a happier meaning in life.

Mustaine 'found God', has an 18 year old son and yet is still a miserable bitch who whinges and bitches about the past. Great role model for his children. :y:

For the record, I'm a fan of both, I'm not Anti-Dave or anything, just saying really...

Why the fuck would you look to a couple of angry fuckheads from Metal acts as role models?

They all like to gang up on me because they think it's funny. :(

No, because we know how you like being ganged up on by a bunch of dudes. :naughty:

That, and contrary to your worldview, a lot of people actually don't like Metallica, and not for whatever shitty excuses you use to prop up your man crush.

So you are telling me that making slow whiney songs doesnt discredit you for being a metal band? Wait why am I arguing with the guy who fervently watches power rangers about the values of metal?

Power Rangers themes are TOTALLY metal, man. \m/

That aside, they've put out a lot of non-metal material, so yeah. I mean, anyone who pretends "Unforgiven" and its sixteen spinoffs (Auspie note: No, Kalyx, this is hyperbole. You don't need to correct me) is metal might as well call Chris Daughtry Thrash, but that doesn't invalidate their prior body of work.

As metal. It's already invalid on the grounds of quality. "FOUR CHORDS AND THE TRUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUTHAHHHHHHHHHHHH!" Is just as faggy, but it's not metal.

[Kalyx triaD]

THERE WAS ONLY THREE UNFORGIVENS :foc:

[Rammsteinmad]

Why the fuck would you look to a couple of angry fuckheads from Metal acts as role models?

Because I'm referring to the role Dave Mustaine should be playing to his children. Heaven's forbid who'd wanna set a good example for their children these days eh? :roll: