They have all seen it. Get real here. And youre right, hes an authentic promo and would make a great manager.

Give him the "TNA Orlando Jordan" Gimmick.

I thought Brock was fairly decent in UFC. Punk, not even a little bit.

Brock won the fucking heavyweight title. No dispute there.

Wouldnt be shocked if he is a HoFer

I enjoyed watching Brock beat Frank Mir bloody.

But I also really enjoyed CM Punk getting destroyed.

Even with the PEDs?

Thats the one thing that could keep him out..time will tell

As more and more guys fail tests at one point or another, that point becomes mute, I think.

Fact is, he became world champ in a sport where guys train relentlessly since childhood and are multidiscipline fighters who just move so smoothly on instinct. And he conquered that world.

He should never have taken Overeem fight so soon after intestinal surgery.

I think he was really impressive overall

The point about Punk getting his ass handed to him is really valid. The WWE would have to pretend that it never happened. Which they would. There is no way that CM Punk becomes a mainstream draw for the WWE now. Not a chance. If the music hit? I definitely think he would get a pop, because the nerds pop at anything once or twice. But that stink is definitely going to be there -- it has come up in this conversation.

I guarantee the WWE would just bring him back and act as if he never left. But a large part of that goes against the "authenticity" of that Punk gimmick. It's hard to get around. Perhaps the best thing to do would be to bring him back as a commentator, have a lower-card heel punk him out, he gets up, beats the piss out of them, says he's not done yet, etc. To make it seem like he's good in the WWE but shit in UFC is a pretty dumb move.