Would You Want to Hear Jim Ross in UFC?
 

From J.R.'s blog:

"The UFC upper mgmt people know that I have an interest in their product and I think that my style would fit what they do quite well especially when they begin expanding their roster of broadcasters."

I'm so used to the sound of Rogan and Goldberg. Would you guys want to hear a three man booth or maybe even just have J.R. on play by play and Rogan on color?

Honestly I think it'd be pretty cool, but I can't see it happening.

No fucking way.. If anyone was the third commentator itd have to be Randy couture..

It would definitely be weird hearing about slobberknockers in the UFC.

"Bah Gawd What a Head Kick!"

JON JONES

JON JONES

JON JONES!(As the camera mans throw's 'Bones' a couple of budweisers when he celebrates a victory)

Does JR have enough knowledge on MMA to call it properly?

Never held him back in wrestling.

A better question is: Does he know MMA's not fake?

You're just jealous that he has a better body than you.

No, I like Goldberg and Rogan, and hate JR.

GOGOPLATA! GOGOPLATA! GOGOPLATA! BAH GAWD HE CHOKED HIM OUT JOE!

I wouldn't mind hearing that one time.

He wouldn't do fine.. He knows prowrestling and has been around since the late 80's and he still sucked at that..

Horrible horrible idea..

Gonna have to disagree with that Krispy. :wavesad:

He did do the XFL. :shifty:

It has nothing to do with that.. It has to do with Jim Ross being absolute shit..

Get Joey styles in the mix and I'd be fine with it..

He's not shit actually. Yes, I would want to see him in MMA

Aww...Did you get offended that I called wrestling fake?

He is horrible with dated cliches and stupid hillbilly terminology.. The reason UFC commentating is good is it's real.. Not that the sport is real bit their reaction to bad calls by the ref and whatnot.. JR has spent the better part of 20 years selling storlines not actually commentating..

i wouldn't want to see him in mma. i am guessing he doesn't have a scooby when it comes to the intricate parts of guard passing etc. i'm sure he'd be great when guy a was stood across from guy b punching him in the face, but during the slower parts he would be grim.

i will pair up with krispy on this and hope for a couture/rutten commentary team

Yes!! Bas FN Rutten!!!

not a fan of goldberg to be honest. The guy sounds like he likes hearing his own voice sometimes.

no

Goldy is awesome.. He has the voice and is uber knowledgable.. I only gets bad when he ties to act "cool" which isn't often.. He plays off Rogan well..

<object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/C31Vu6B9MFI?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/C31Vu6B9MFI?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>

will JR be rocking the cowboy hat?

It would be interesting to hear JR and King call ONE fight, but only one.

Jim Ross is a thousand times the commentator Joey Styles is was or will ever be. Such a faggy ECW fanboy thing to say, though I guess I'm not surprised.

What?

I just wanted to make fun of you.

Styles has a knowledge of submission wrestling which is a much better asset than slobbering on a microphone..

Commentators don't need a knowledge of anything, they need a command of the facts and a good memory for stats and winning runs and that kind of shit. The analysis and real knowledge is supplied by the co-commentator, in this case Joe Rogan or Randy Couture, that's the way it needs to be. Who gives a fuck if JR takes over, except that it will sound faintly ridiculous hearing a guy normally playing a character doing it straight? Mike Goldberg literally imparts fuck all insight to a UFC fight and is there to sound ethusiastic, shout "IT'S ALLLL OVER" and other cliched catchphrases.

Anyone who says Goldberg doesn't add actual play by play and analysis doesn't watch UFC..

goldberg is kind of shit. i'm not a fan. plus he relies on his catchphrases too often. my dream team is rogan and rutten :'(

I think a Rogan/ Bas combo would still need a guy like Goldberg to keep them from going on random tangents or rambling.... A Bob Costas or Joe Buck type guy who is talented and entertaining, but isn't going to overwhelm the show with his voice or personality.

I do think the MMA crowd would eat J.R. alive the second he screwed up just because he comes from wrestling.

Are you fucking stupid?

What about Pride's Mauro Ronallo (sp?). He's quite knowledgable and is a fan of pro wrestling

What does being a fan of pro wrestling have to do with anything?



I think Rogan sometimes makes Goldberg look worse than he actually is.

No but you are obviously ignorant of he situation to throw out petty insults instead of adding to the discussion..

Bottom line is, you have to have a play by play guy for the color commentator to play off of.. Goldberg makes alot of good calls on anticipating what a fighter is setting up by what they are doing, etc.. He is on point on boxing knowledge and willing tells viewers what combos the corners are calling for.. His grappling knowledge has grow leaps and bounds over the past 7 years..

Anyone who argues that has not watched enough UFC to realize that or just plain out isnt knowledgable about the sport to see it..

But I guess you won't argue any of hose points do to the fact you'll prolly spent too much effort coming up with a quip about my intelligence or weight..

Jim Ross can call straight when it comes down to it. When they needed him to call wrestling matches and not sell storylines he was good, and he "played" straight.

I think people would be surprised.

Joey Styles would suck at MMA, he's more over the top than JR and sounds like a moron. "OH MY GODDDDD" fucking he sounds like such a god damned retard.

I did add to the discussion you stupid dickhead. I made a post and the next one was you striding in here with your usual thick-headed but strangely condescending comment. You're supposedly a mod in this forum, behave like one. If you've just answered like you had here in the first place, you wouldn't have this happening now.

I also love that the reflex, even when you are attempting to discuss this properly, is to suggest that anyone who disagrees with you just doesn't know enough about the sport.

Anyone who has watched ANY sport knows how it works. Goldberg is there because he can talk alot, sound enthusiastic and keep the commentary flowing on air. He blatantly does not offer any real insight into the fights, that is Joe Rogan's place, Goldberg is there to ask the sort of questions a novice who has never fought would ask.

Any new commentator, it would be their job to know about stats, names of moves, winning runs, fighter histories. They would work on it. The real decision on whether a commentator works or not is how they sound on-screen and if they can fill the air.

What i dont get is how Goldberg doesn't do that?? As I said he has all of striking knowledge and does add fighter history.. I have never heard him unprepared for a fight.. He knows the fighters and their trainers, including changes in training during camps..

JR has sold storylines not fights so anyone who would put him over a guy who took the job from the first mma play by play guy, who was bland and boring (Jeff blatnick), is nothing more than a wwe fanboy..

While I more than likely would not want Ross calling MMA fights... my problem with Krispy's argument is that he talks about how Goldberg has learned all this stuff and knows so much. What would keep Ross from learning all this stuff? What could keep Ross from learning about the training camps? About the trainers? Fighter histories? All that?

Ross could be more than capable of doing it and doing a good job. He could learn everything that Goldberg has learned over the years in order to do a sufficient job. He won't be a Goldberg but he isn't there to be a Goldberg. He's there to be a Jim Ross. I think you're just coming down far too hard on Ross for really no reason other than he used to call storylines in WWE. Like because of that he wouldn't be capable of calling anything else any other way and that is absurd.

...I never said he didn't do all of that. His boxing knowledge isn't that clever, anyway, not sure where you get that from. In saying that, I've never really been a fan of American boxing commentators vs. the guys we have over here.

What I am saying is that he's not there for his expertise. JR could do all of that, pretty much any announcer could transfer between sports if they were willing to put in the work. Plenty of commentators do multiple sports too, I'm sure MMA is not the only sport Mike Goldberg has ever worked on given that sports broadcasters tend to do many different things. It's his job to know about fighters records, camps, backgrounds. If it was someone else's job, they would do it too.

He is part of UFC because he has the voice and the catchphrases. If he were replaced, I wouldn't miss any of his insight because he offers none.

Joe rogan talks about commentating with goldy in one of these videos...

<object width="640" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/XE8kVgwX8Gg?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/XE8kVgwX8Gg?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="640" height="385"></embed></object>

<object width="640" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/pWHzVaGj0KQ?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/pWHzVaGj0KQ?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="640" height="385"></embed></object>

Goody learned from like UFC 12 to the present, not when the UFC is the biggest combat sport in the world..

JR is a sports commentator who got his big break in Pro Wrestling. For the most part all commentators are sports fans and their job is to call the action. There's no reason to say JR couldn't do that. There are many hockey commentators who hockey wasn't their first love but it's their first big break into the business.

Just because Goldberg started at UFC 12 doesn't mean he's any better than anybody else. He has his own style which is great, and JR has his own as well. It's pretty easy to figure out stats especially with the interwebz so I don't think JR would have any problem.

I think one slight problem with JR is that he isn't the most attentive to details. In wrestling it's easy to go off on tangents or make one liners, but MMA is different. Is J.R. at his age and after all he's done willing to learn these technical move names and learn the backgrounds, nuances, and quirks of all these fighters?

Sure anyone can learn, but would he or would he just try to get by calling all the heavyweights hosses, saying all the black fighters were the best athletes the UFC has to offer, calling fights sloober knockers, and getting visibly erect every time Brock Lesnar's name is mentioned?

As a play by play as proven by Mike Goldberg, attention to detail isn't that big of a deal. Krispy just wants to be cool and hate on JR.

No I don't want UFC to bring in non mma personalities when it's the best it's ever been.. Firstly Goldberg and Rogan are the best commentator crew in all of sports and neither need to be replaced.. If they were to change things up use some one like Couture, who has already done it numerous times and there is no question he is more knowledgeable than someone who doesn't come from a combat sport background..

JR is a horrible choice and its not as much as menhating on JR than you guys being retardedly fanboyish..

I'd rather hem bring back Blatnick, who I hatEd, than to bring in Jim Ross..

Post this on sherdog or any actual mma board and see what reaction you get..

When it was first posted I thought it was a joke..

It has nothing to do with him coming from a "fake sport" though.. It comes from him not coming from a combat sport background.. Goldberg can hang cause he has had like 15 years to become good.. With ufc's popularity at an all time high, it would be stupid to being in anyone who is not a "sure thing"..

Pretty sure Rogan and Goldberg are nowhere near the best pair in "all of sports."

Aikman & Buck > Rogan & Goldberg

With the addition of the rest of the WEC weight classes and the UFC planning on putting on 30 something fights next year I definitely see them adding another commentary team.

Maybe save Rogan & Goldberg for the PPVs and let the "B" team work the preliminary matches and free Spike t.v. Fight Nights. If they were to bring someone like J.R. in, starting him on those shows would be the smarter move than throwing him in with Rogan and Goldberg right away.

Aikman and buck want to have a gay 3way with Romo..

Yeah, I would like to see Liddell join the commentary team.

No way in hell would I want to hear Liddell on commentary. I love the Ice Man, but the dude speaks like his brain is on a ten second delay. It's from all the years of fighting for the fans, I understand that, but still...

He is way too soft spoken and shy..

Couture or Kenflo

lol true i forgot about his interviews.

JR was terrible towards the end of his WWE run, I remember him calling Shawn Michaels 'JTG' & 'John Morrison' in the same match. Fair enough with Morrison, but JTG is a black guy in his twenties.....

If we were talking the JR from 10 years ago, I'd say easily. The guy would probably be just ok for the first show, but he'd pick it up fairly quickly. Now though, Mofo is right. He's not the same as he once was and probably retired for that reason.

The commentators we have now are oustanding. Why do people try and fix shit that isnt broken...

So true, watching the early UFC's is painful with the commentary.

Jim Brown, some lady, and Jeff Blatnick

:n:

I love how back then nobody knew anything about anything...even the fighters didn't know shit.

it was brutal watching a guy tap for about 15 seconds before the ref stopped it though :'(

Blatnick was by far the most knowledgable until Goldberg signed on.. That's why everyone who is saying he doesn't know his shit don't know what they are talking about..

Definitely would not want to hear JR in UFC. I'm sorry, but he doesn't even take the time to learn the names of wrestling moves, I definitely don't want to hear him call a Kimura "What a submission move."

JoRo and Goldberg are fine. Rogan is pretty much money, I mean the guy has gone to training camps to learn shit just so he could call it better. That's some dedication there. IF they were going to add another guy, it should be Couture or Kenny Florian, both guys who are knowledgeable, and can talk well.

Although if push came to shove, I'd say JR over Liddel, as Liddel is pretty much brain dead.

BAH GAWD, IT IS AAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLL OOOVER

I bought TUF season 11 cause I hadn't seen it.. When dana asked both Liddell and Ortiz who the top 4 fighters and Liddell was like "i don't know".. Dana is like "you don't know??" and he's like "yeah, I don't know"..

Dana's reaction was hilarious..

Was TUF 11 any good? I'm thinking of going back to catch up.

So how do we all expect fights happening in India at the same time that they're happening in Brazil without more than one broadcast team?

Why would the UFC schedule a fight in India and Brazil at the same time? Why would they even schedule those fights in the same month? I'm sure logistics goes into consideration when they plan the "MOTHERFUCKINFREE" on Spike T.V. shows and the PPVs.

No idea what Ben rodrigues is talking about..

Watch some of the Dana White Q&A's - this appears to be the direction the company going in with it getting so big that they can have fights happening all over the world at the same time. All viewable from the comfort of your computer screen.

Don't think that will happen..

I think Stephan Bonnar is being groomed to go into commentary or hosting one day. He's not that bad.

UFC wants to go into the India and China markets for events just like they have done in Germany, Australia, Canada, and the UK. I don't see them competing against themselves for ratings by putting on multiple events on the same night.

I think Dana said his ultimate goal was something like having shows all around the world, and have multiple versions of TUF going on at once, and having a huge TUF card where fighters from the various TUF's face off.

That's great but only the live shows would need commentating so Rogan and Goldy could handle it..