Gash or Gold - CSL Judges Your Favorite Wrestling Moments, Matches, and Memories!
 

It is quite simple. Post in this thread some of your favorite matches, moments, and memories. TPWW Icon, CSL, will then judge those moments and give them a rating of either GASH (aka dogshit) or GOLD (aka Triple H's Indian Deathlock).

I'll begin:

Moments
Triple H returns at MSG - 2001
Ric Flair's Promo on Triple H before their world title match - 2002

Matches
Triple H vs Ric Flair (Late 2005 feud)

Memories
Crowbar winning the WCW Hardcore Championship (2000?)

Is CSL really on board for this? If so, I'm totally in.

Yes. CSL is a man of the people and will pleasure us with his opinions.

Match
Shawn Michaels v. The British Bulldog for the Intercontinental title @ SNME in 1992

Moment
Hawk falls off the Titan Tron

Memory
Earthquake kills Damien

I dont understand what is different in Moment and Memory...

Match - Elimination Chamber, Summerslam 2003 (Goldberg Smash!)

Moment - Jake Roberts returns to Raw (7:00) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hthYkUWseEI

lol CSL will never judge everything posted.

Moment - Something you vividly remember and the time/place
Memory - Something you remember, but it might be a bit foggy or you're off on specific date/time/event/etc.

Plus, it is good alliteration.

going to do it now just to PROVE YOU WRONG

http://img237.imageshack.us/img237/5...0benoitft1.jpg

In honor of CSL, I present to you the official theme song of this thread:

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/_0vCqEgarBY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

GOLD. Homeboy was the best wrestler on earth from pretty much the moment Austin had his surgery onwards, probably hasn't been a more credible heel world champion since with mayyybe the exception of Brock. Deserved every bit of the reaction he got.

G-onna need a video of this. If not, it's Flair cutting a promo so it's probably GOLD.

only one I remember off the top of my head is the PPV cage match. In which case it's gotta be GOLD. Always enjoyed Triple H and Flair against each other, simple matches with simple stories that pull the crowd in, perfect timing, Trips always going out of his way to make Flair look good and Flair being Flair. Flair went over clean and decisively (by cage match standards) in the one I'm thinking of too, which was a nice surprise.

don't recall the specific match/finish etc, my brain has probably blocked a lot of WCW from around that time out as self preservation. But Crowbar was meh, Reno was meh (except Roll the Dice, which was immense) so I guess I'd have to go GASH.

God, I loved this whole one-night storyline. Austin forced HHH to defend the title against a former world champion of his choice. HHH picks Flair and expects him to lay down. They have HBK and others talk to him. Flair then cuts this epic promo on HHH saying he is getting Flair's best tonight. Then, they put on an awesome match where I seriously thought Ric Flair was going to once again become the heavyweight champion of the world.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/0vZRn29ESD0" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Seriously, Jim Ross being at his best and the storyline and the emotion of the whole night gets my heart racing just thinking about it. I still think they probably should have given Flair the belt that night.

Thought the cage match was awesome and that the last man standing match the next ppv was a 5 star classic

I enjoyed the promo. It's not quite "classic Flair" but it's better than most. GOLD.

beyond GOLD. Was a huge HBK fan from almost day one (obligatory "worship Hogan" phase)/started to really favour the heels just as HBK was getting that initial singles push. Remember reading about it in WWF magazine whilst standing in a shop and being happy as a bastard. "Enjoyable match", creative finish that advanced/didn't harm either guy.

probably have to say GASH. As daft and sometimes entertaining the "Hawk being pissed up" stuff was, after seeing the Road Warriors doc piece and knowing he was going through a really shit time whilst doing it/it being a bit too close to home and then his death being an indirect result of his "demons", it's just a bit ugly. That and Droz was a bit shit.

what's not to love about this? Ridiculous looking 400lb heel fatty in an old school-cut singlet (and no kneepads) does that daft "Earthquake bouncing around the ring" gimmick before squashing a blokes pet snake whilst everybody plays it dead serious. And the kids ate it all up. It's glorious, it's the original "Bossman feeds Al Snow his dog". GOLD.

WE'RE IN GREENVILLE SOUTH CAROLINA AND RIC FLAIRS GOT HIS GAME FACE ON

Moment
Marty Janetty attempts to escape Shawn Michaels by diving through the barbershop window

Match
Ric Flair vs Mr Perfect - Monday Night Raw Loser Retires

Memory
Earthquake sits on Hulk Hogan, sidelining him for months and causing him to consider retirement

Pretty much anything HHH related is dogshit

Match - Sting and Flair vs Muta and Funk in the Thunderdome - Still my all time favorite.

Moment - Buff Bagwell punches another in a long line of fake stings, only to have it be real sting. He then Drops Bagwell, takes of the Sting mask to reveal face paint, and clears the ring.

Memory - Can barely remember the match, but was a somewhat early ECW match where Saturn drops and elbow off the scaffold in a scaffold match to a guy in the ring. Biggest fucking spot I ever saw at that point and was one of my first ECW memories. I remember just being shocked and trying to explain how amazing it was to my friends. Woke up every saturday at 7AM to watch ECW from then on.

Billy Gunn vs The Rock

It's on the ECW - Extreme Evolution dvd

Eliminators VS Terry Gordy & Steve Williams.
(This was possibly the weakest match on this DVD but it has it's moments as Saturn does a great elbow drop from a board near the ceiling used in scaffold matches.Also Dr Death Steve Williams gets powerbombed on the concrete floor.The match is from High Incident in October 1996)***

Legit interested in CSL'a view on Daniel Bryan's first year in WWE.

solid GOLD right here. First time Goldberg was really booked to his strengths on a big scale in WWE and it showed, built towards his entry into the match and when it happened, the crowd ate up every second of it. Few guys ever have been capable of drawing that kind of reaction by doing a few moves and looking at the crowd and old Billy showed he was one of them right here. Gotta credit Triple H and Flair as well, the cowardly heel stuff and Goldberg getting them anyway was the perfect payoff. They made a mistake not putting the belt on him however, was definitely "the right time" as opposed to a month later.

have to say GOLD just for the spectacle of Jake being on TV, the reaction he got, how much it clearly meant to him etc. Unfortunately he looked like he'd been dragged to the show backwards, promo wasn't up to "Jake standards" but I'd rather it have happened than not, it accomplished what is was supposed to.

match: 10 Man Tag Team match at Canadian Stampede '97. So much energy, so much story, just awesome.

Memory: Bret Harts profanity laced tirade on Raw after losing the title to Sid.

Moment: Don't ask me why but Marc Mero fucking up his knee on a drop to the outside sticks with me. Very Willis MaGahee in the way it bent.

Not a fan of Bret Hart but for whatever reason he is included in 2 of these

Thats sounds right. Its often in many highlight films on ECW but just that moment sticks with me, nothing else about the match.

Was it Marc Mero or Scott Putski?

GOLD. Amazing launch pad for Michaels as a singles guy (and who knows, could have been great for Marty if he wasn't so "Marty") the fact people still reference and talk about it 21 years later says it all.


I was never as big of a fan of this as anybody else. Love Flair, love Perfect, just feels like a really underwhelming exit for Flair and nothing was built on it for Hennig. But it was a different time back then, no PPV really close enough to build towards (I believe Flair wanted out asap so Mania was probs out of the question) The competitors and match itself definitely place it on the side of GOLD but it's not as overwhelming as anything involving these two should be.

GOLD. If only for Hogan's twitchy leg sell. Not to mention the kids eating it up and those poor bastards that sent Hogan get well cards still receiving WWE catalogues in the mail. And the blow off match at Summerslam provided us with Hogan tearing Earl Hebner's shirt to pieces mid-match. That was different.

You may be right. For some reason I was thinking it was the "Wildman"

I believe it was Scott Putski in a match with Brian Christopher at some PPV somewhere. In Your House or something.

Ground Zero, turns out. The second clip here is a BRIEF shot of it.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/Embzk4yL4x8" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

That's it! Thanks, ABT. Still cringeworthy

Yeah, that was gross.

Match: RVD and Sabu vs Hayabusa and Jinsei Shinzaki at Heatwave. Fav match ever.

Moment: Heyman tells A.P.A that only Simmons is fired and Bradshaw isn't. JBL begins.

Memory: anybody remember an angle where Hugh Morrus's dad would all of a sudden walk down the aisle confused during his matches?

I don't remember it, but I can't think of a reason that WCW would be like "It'd be rad if Hugh Morrus' dad walked in the aisle looking confused during his matches". Clearly that is what killed WCW

It was very very weird. As usual, nothing came of it.

I do wonder what Hugh Morrus' dad looks like now, which may have been their endgame I guess.

Ok I wasn't making this up:
During a match this Hennig some old guy walks down the ramp in a hospital gown. Morrus calls him "pops" and escorts him back up the ramp. Morrus slams Hennig and his "pops" comes back down and Morrus goes back outside the ring. Hennig wins with a Hennigplex.
Pops comes down to console Morrus and mimics him.

This occured on the December 20th 1999 Nitro so this has Russo's fingers all over it.

that seems like an Ed Ferrera idea to me

Match
HBK vs Taker II - HBK's retirement match at Mania 26

Moment
Jericho's "It Never Happened" title victory over Triple H on RAW in 2000

Memory
Mr Perfect showing off his perfect skills by catching a football he threw.

Match
Kenta Kobashi and Tsuyoshi Kikuchi vs. Doug Furnas and Dan Kroffat from May 25th 1992


-Wrestling Observer's Match of the Year for 1992. It's a favorite of mine as well.

<iframe width="640" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/RY5NDCCoUNs?feature=player_detailpage" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Moment
Ric Flair winning the 1992 Royal Rumble & Post Match Speech

Memory
The 4 Horsemen break Dusty Rhodes' arm
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/6_KCuwQrsmw?feature=player_detailpage" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Seth82 vs The 21st Century

Match
Shane v. Angle Street Fight 2001

Moment
Jeff Swanton off the Titan Tron

Memory
Steph Turns On Vince

I woulda thought you woulda said when The Hardy Boy'z rassled the Dudley Boy'z and Edge and Christian at Rasslemania.

Slacking off so soon? How dare you actually spend the weekend doing other stuff!

Match
RVD vs Big Show - "Philly Screwjob" RVD loses the ECW title

Moment
Nexus Dismantles the ring

Memory
Daniel Bryan calls out Michael Cole.

I havenae seen this :( I would almost guarantee GOLD by the guys in it but not checking it out first would have been a GASH move

glorious GOLD. The Buff strut gimmick with Sting no-selling the punch/waiting for him to finish before the reverse DDT was a great visual.

it's not bad. Given the choice between GASH or GOLD, I'd have to lean towards GOLD because it was admittedly "PrettyCool"/Iop but I didn't really enjoy the "sit down, shuffle a bit, lower yourself a bit" etc just because it's like, dude is supposed to not care about his body but that stuff screams the opposite (I obviously understand why he did it) New Jack would have just fucking gone for it ;)

GOLD. For all of the obvious blatant reasons that have been spoken of for 17 years now. That said, didn't enjoy the finish. But I think that's more to do with the directing of the show as opposed to the actual finish.

not sure which one you mean. The cage match one when he shoves Vince?

don't recall this (and apparently it turns out it was Scott Putski) but I have no desire to see it, guys getting injured or even generally taking awkward looking bumps makes me cringe. Even if I knew what you meant and watched the match again, I'd turn away when that part came about. Definite GASH.

Match:

Disco Inferno Beats Alex Wright for the TV title.

Moment:

Disco Inferno Beats Saturn for the TV title.

Memory:

Disco inferno does a fake music video parody of Konnan OIL OF OLAY!

I'll get those out of the way for you right now

GASH

GASH


GASH

I forget he was ever even TV champion once until I was watching some Goldberg streak videos a while back and he showed up with the belt

(Chartbuster to CSL)

I thought Disco Inferno was a fine TV champ.

Match:
TLC III (Jericho & Benoit/Edge & Christian/Hardys/Dudleys)

Moment:
Kurt Angle's milk truck
Ric Flair returns the night after Survivor Series 2001

Memory:
Tony Chimel announcing Edge as the Rated-R Sooooooooperstar

Rewatched the RVD/Sabu vs Shinzaki/Hayabusa Heatwave 98 match I posted. Not as amazing as I remembered, although Hayabusa was soooooooo good.

and now he's dead(from the neck down)

Love you, CSL. Your opinions on wrestling are definitley GOLD.

Match: Billy Kidman vs. Paul London from No Mercy 2004.

Moment: William Regal's promo on Triple H sometime in 2004, or around then. Triple H was bullying Eugene around and Regal stood up to Triple H, bringing up their past and telling Triple H that taking advantage of that disadvantaged boy was one of the stupidest things he has ever done, because now he's gone and made an enemy out of him.

Memory: Kane dominates in the 2001 Royal Rumble.

thought it was "standard ECW fare", like it was pretty good/fun but didn't stand out as anything special. Definitely GOLD as opposed to GASH however, RVD was the best "unheard of" talent in wrestling at the time, Hayabusa was great, Sabu was still fucking SABU. Did enjoy the double legdrop gimmick. My favourite part tho is probably the pre-match promo *HAKUSHI!* Van Dam showed more character and charisma in that promo than any promo he ever cut in WWE or TNA.

GOLD. I enjoyed this, the swerve was something a bit different, it achieved what it needed to and it gave birth to a character/performer so strong/comfortable in the gimmick that practically overnight JBL was launched to the top of the card. That's Justin Hawk Bradshaw, WWE champion.

have never heard of this :S

GASH. Bit controversial I know but it wasn't as good as HBK/Taker 1 and it was the exit of Shawn Michaels as an in-ring performer. A nice send-off sure, a fitting send-off absolutely. But as a Shawn Michaels fan from the age of about 7 ft. (awful) homemade HBK tights, it was something that was never supposed to happen. Even in the build up to the match it never once occurred to me that this was actually going to be the end of HBK, it was something I never really believed was going to happen. "How does somebody that good, that still outperforms 100% of the wrestlers on Earth on a nightly basis, walk away?" My reasoning is entirely selfish obviously, it's still a very good match, off the top of my head maybe somewhere in the top 5 or 10 matches from the last 5 or 10 Manias but if they'd have stopped after 25 and HBK carried on forever, I'd have been a lot happier http://www.tpwwforums.com/images/icons/icon12.gif

GOLD. I don't need to go into depth as to why, it's really obvious. The crowd response, the shock, Triple H at his absolute best etc, one of the better moments in RAW history.

Solid GOLD. All of those ridiculous Perfect vignettes were, so simple but so good. Or even "perfect" (SEE WHAT I DID THERE) but 4realz, love everything about them. May be a bit biased because Hennig is top 5 all time for me but whatevs Trevs.

Match- In your house 8.2: Beware of Dog- Caribbean Strap Match- Savio Vega vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Moment- Edge cashes in on John Cena to win his first WWE Title AFTER Cena wins the Elimination Chamber

Memory- Undertaker's promo on the tron from inside the casket after he lost the casket match at the 1994 Royal Rumble

how did you feel about that sweet jumping Tombstone at the end of Michaels/Taker 2?

I for one thought it was sweet

not sure which one you mean. The cage match one when he shoves Vince?


Yes, sir

Match: Bret Hart vs British Bulldog WWF title match @ In Your House
Moment: DX takes the piss out of the nation
Memory: Joey Mercury getting his face rearranged by Jeff Hardy jumping on a ladder

Bret Hart doing anything on-screen in the past 5 years

Miss Kitty flashing her tatars at Armageddon 99? Not sure if it was 99. Think it was. Dunno.

Jeff Jarrett's rise to prominence in WCW in it's dying years.

Jeff Jarrett vs Chyna Intercontinental title feud.

Mae Young showing her tatars at Royal Rumble 2000.

Raw 1999:
http://www.wwe.com/f/styles/ep_trend...000228_mae.jpg

RAW1000:
http://cdn.wl.uproxx.com/wp-content/...g_hand_son.png

never seen it. Shall watch at some point.

GOLD. Flair had been working for Vince for like what, 3 months tops? And he gets the title from almost the get go. Shows the greatness of the guy right there. Love the whole story, Flair was perfect throughout the match (and in the promo) My favourite part of the whole thing however is still and always will be Bobby Heenan (and Hennig), on commentary and after rushing off to join in the celebrations afterwards. The whole thing was just great. GOLD GOLD GOLD.[/quote]

have really liked this since the very first time I saw it. Feel like we should see more things like this in modern day wrestling, one of those things that would really "add realism" that also makes perfect sense. GOLD.

GOLD. The real arrival of "Shane the super non-worker". Had no business having a match anywhere near this good for a guy that isn't a professional wrestler (tho the fact he was in with Angle certainly doesn't hurt) Was actually showing this to a friend recently, such a brutal match as well, the thud when Shane's head hits the floor on one of the failed suplex's is sickening. Great stuff.

"Holy shit, Jeff Hardy is going to get the push." GOLD for the reason alone.

More GOLD. Kickstarted the power couple gimmick. As much as they dominated TV afterwards, the Triple H/Steph in control stuff/Vince leaving was great TV, both were/are great heels for very different reasons, Steph went from dull daughter of Vince to entertaining bitch that suddenly became really quite hot. Plus the angle/turn itself was very well done/perfectly executed and YOU DIDN'T. SEE IT. COMING. BANG! Still only the 2nd most over thing I remember from the show however, 1st obvs being Miss Kitty's tatars

Moment

Big Show and Miz defeat DX and the Straight Edge Society on February 8, 2009 making Miz a triple champion (holding the United States & Unified WWE Tag Team [World Tag Team and WWE Tag Team] championships).


Match

Rock vs. Austin III, WrestleMania XIX, Sunday, March 30, 2003


Memory

Although defeated, Hollywood Hulk Hogan shakes The Rock's hand graciously at WrestleMania X8, and The Rock reciprocates by allowing Hogan to pose for the fans for several minutes in-ring.

Match -- Triple H vs Taka Michinou (RAW 2000)

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/3I-iUL2IBn4" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Moment -- Triple H dresses up as Goldust and uses a flamethrower on Kane.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/aiJzEkWVBD8" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Memory -- Triple H turns heel at WrestleMania XV

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/OF3zoiJdvwI" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

The WWE Championship wasn't part of that.

GASH. For the same kind of reason I'd call Vince blowing up in the limo GASH and so forth. It was something that we never got to see extend to it's true potential/really see where it was going due to the Van Dam bust/subsequent punishment/"outside forces".

GOLD. One of those rare "you HAVE to see this", the kind of thing that makes wrestling fans giddy because they know something "big"/gamechanging just happened. Very well executed angle, can't really ask for a better way to introduce a bunch of new guys to the "main audience".

Solid GOLD. Loved this so much. Was frothing for them to go in this direction with Daniel Bryan at the time since it was all very well played by the 2 guys involved and it was by far the most interesting he'd been since the start of NXT. He's the best guy FOR. THIS. JOB. Nice bit of foreshadowing right there.

Match


John Cena vs. Shawn Michaels, RAW 2007


<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/C8p9IBITM6I" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>


Moment

Tazz returns to ECW as WWE wrestler, takes ECW Title from Mike Awesome, WCW wrestler


<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/iFaT0_6kEqI" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>


Memory


Jericho being carried away kicking and screaming after being "fired" by Bischoff, RAW 2005.

Thanks, edited it. Better now?

Yep!

Let's hope CSL feels that way. While I would like to get at least one GOLD from him, he has had it in for me around here ever since 2009, when I argued (and rightly so) that because Jamie Noble had been released from the main roster (or had to retire from the active roster because of Sheamus attacking him), even though he was still a behind-the-scenes guy of some sort, that I should recieve credit for having him on my Pink Slip Pool 2009 list, and was immediately and repeatedly refused by Mr. SL.

lol you better give him a GOLD for that post now, Chandler.

Even though you were clearly in the wrong, I forgive you and accept your apology, sir. To err is human, to forgive is to put an issue behind you...only to bring that issue right back up again and re-start the whole damn thing. That's the only way to move forward in life.

Wait, if that’s actually his real first name, i.e. same as one of the guys from Friends, that is amazing.

Match:
Kurt Angle vs Shawn Michaels 30 minute Ironman Match

Moment:
The reveal of "Double Dave" Hebner during the Hogan/Andre/DiBiase stuff.

Memory:
Jerry Lawler and Andy Kaufman on David Letterman. Was the first time I was allowed to stay up past the late local news.

At age 16?????

I'm not quite THAT old.

I was 9, almost 10 at the time.

Well I can't say GASH because it was a "fun" match but it wasn't TLC I or II GOLD. Was a bit of a waste giving it away on TV but I understand the reasons for it/why they attempted it. The Jeff leapfrog spot still stands out. GOLD.

GOLD obvs. But more for everything that came before Angle actually showed up. Austin throughout the entire "appreciation night" gimmick was GOLD. Austin throughout 2001 in general actually was GOLD. Probably one of the most famous segments ever.

GOLD. Probably the most GOLD thing in here so far. Strictly because it was responsible for the greatest facial in the history of pro wrestling

http://www.totalprosports.com/wp-con...funny-face.gif

GASH. It's all GOLD until he hits the SOO part and then it goes to shit. Howard Finkel would have provided the great Rated R Superstar the world has ever seen. They'd still talk about it in 30 years time.

Feel like most the stuff here falls quite clearly in GOLD/GASH territory and therefore doesn't really need to be asked. However, I'm failing to think of anything divisive enough to get an opinion on.

Way to over think this thread, you fucking douche.

You've become so defensive since your Survivor rip-off went down like a lead balloon. Relax.

Fuck you.

"Overthinking" has become James Steele's "strawman".

Much like continuing to be a utter shite poster has become your "thing"?

Aww snap.

I know it isn't very original, but I call a spade a spade and a piece of shit a piece of shit.

A speckled piece of shit a la WWE's booking?

WWE's booking is flawless, you know that. Vince McMahon's ball sweat could book a better show than any man alive.