If the rumours are true about a Captain America movie then who should be the lead?
 

This is one movie that simply can't be messed up. I think the guy that played the lead in "thank you for smoking" would make a brilliant Cap. What do you think?

Apparently the frontrunner is Matthew McConaughey

I thought it was Corporal America now.

Woody Allen :shifty:

Honoustly guys, it's got to be Will Smith

That could really work once you think about it

But before you think about it.. no way!

then suggest an alternative

Tom Cruise tbh

I honestly believe Mark Wahlberg would make an awesome Captain America.

I wasn't disagreeing.. I was just making fun of the way you said it.

your avatar freaks me out to be honest also.

Its gunna end up being someone really shitty like Vin Diesle.

Tony Almeida should be Captain America.

Before I came in here I had no idea who would be a good Cap but yeah I've become a fan of Aaron Eckhart (Thank You For Smoking) lately. Matthew being Cap would be like Ben Affleck being Daredevil for me. Mark would be good but he is a little too short.

Also the frontrunner for first superhero movie I wont see

Ant Man! and no special effects needed!

too small in build

Dilana is amazing!

Yeah I don't know who that is.

I think a perfect fit for Cap is:

http://blowingsmokethemovie.com/matt-damon.jpg



so much better than Affleck
, though I don't know if he could get past Affleck's stigma

Russell Crowe

Christian Bale should play every Superhero.

VIN IS GOD

Randy couture should play Captain America

JOHN CENA IS *Dramatic pause* CAPTAIN AMERICA

Brendon Fraiser (SP? The dude from The Mummy)

play?

You seriously want me to lose my cookies?!

Mr. America

They've already released a preview action figure to show you how it'll look in the film, so I guess it's official.

http://img523.imageshack.us/img523/6...allery1jf7.jpg

Hell yeah this film is gonna rock!

I could actually see

Mark Wahlberg
Matt Damon
Russell Crowe...


it's gotta be somebody with cred.

yup

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...n_Kressley.jpg


Captian America

He definitely looks better in the bat suit.

ahem

um, no it's not.

I could have sworn I heard that somewhere.

No, what you might have heard was "Captain America got shot in the spine, stomach, and chest before being buried in the Arctic by a bunch of weirdos in costumes", not "Captain America receives promotion".

Thats after he retires to civilian life

I thought Randy Couture was Captain America

Damon could easily do it.

Almost nobody's going to look the part, though.

Shaq

:heart:

http://images.eonline.com/eol_images...try.110507.jpg

It makes sense if you don't think about it at all

You beat me to it. When asking anything about anyone, the answer should always be Christian Bale. It overrides the question and provides its own.

Seriously, Aaron Eckhart is a damn good selection, really, but is it likely for a guy to go from a DC Movie to a Marvel one? I guess if Two-Face gets fucked up, there'd be nothing stopping him, but it wouldn't make the studios happy, surely? I'd personally go with an unknown. Find someone who looks the part, with acting skill, and make them into a star with this movie. Well, attempt to.

If it had to be someone with a name, though, I'm going to throw out John C. McGinley. He may not look the part, but if anyone is going to represent an America I'd live in, and it weren't Christian Bale, I'd like it to be Johnny Cox.

If you dyed Brendan Fraser's hair blonde, and he put all his talent into the role (and yes, he does have talent), he could do really well with it.