what do you score him: The Iron Shiek
 

we take a wrestler and score him 1-10 on the following criteria. And then give him a total score.


In ring ability/move set:
look/physique:
finisher:
on the mic:
character development:

total score:

In ring ability/move set: 5 lack of speed hurt him in my eyes. always moved slow
look/physique: 9 not the most defined guy but he looked like the definition of heel
finisher: 8 camel clutch is a nice finisher
on the mic: in his career maybe a 6 because he didn't speak much. today hes a 75!
character development: 6. stayed the course his whole career

total score:34

In ring ability/move set: 4
look/physique: 8
finisher: 8
on the mic: 7
character development: 6

total score: 33

Dear God these threads suck.

The scoring system just doesn't work for one, different things work for different era's. How can you judge Dolph Ziggler, Billy Gunn or Mr. Perfect on the same attributes? Different things matter at different times! How can you judge a high flyer and a big man on the same scale when they offer different things? Numbers are too reductive.

Plus the fact it's just a bunch of numbers on the page. No discussion happens.

This format fails.

777+ anything else is facking bullshit fags!

FragileX you no good motherfucker. I make you humble for that low score! Shiekybaby is a 10 in character. You need camel clutch! Shieky wrestled in Olympic games, so he a 10 in techical skills too.

Ring moves: 8 (an accomplished amateur wrestler but didn't bust out high-agility moves like drop toe holds, enziguris, etc.)
Physique: 8 (was strong as an ox in his prime, had nigh-unbreakable grip, etc. but always had a paunch)
Finisher: 10 (the camel clutch was sold as lethal before it was widely copied and hence cheapened, just like the DDT, and Arnold Skaaland threw in the towel for Bob Backlund because of the clutch)
Promo ability: 8 (always in character but has spammed swearing as a rhetorical crutch)
Character development: 10 (still a mischievous Iranian, but "Sheiky Baby" has amped it up)