![]() |
Bulk of Star Wars Universe no longer considered canon
Lucasfilm dropped the canon status for almost everything outside the original films and Clone Wars stuff for the Star Wars series.
According to George Lucas, the biggest reason was so that the next set of films would have a lot more freedom for its overall story. Quote:
|
I saw this coming. It's whatever.
|
Lucas isn't touching the new films right?
|
He's a consultant.
|
Thought this was announced as a thing pretty much after the new movies were announced.
Never got too big into the Star Wars EU anyways. Always been curious about it, though. I did read that one series, the Junior Jedi Knights or something.... with Han Solo's kids and friends.... remember enjoying them a lot.... |
Never got into the EU stuff. My brother-in-law is way into them and is pissed. I just always took them as recognized fanfic. As well-written as they may or may not be, if they're not direct from the source, I wouldn't consider them canon.
It's like... I don't know, the Left Behind books or something. They're nice supplemental material, but it's not gonna make the big book. |
Wooooooooo If The Force Unleashed is not canon anymore!
Boooooooooo! The Thrawn Trilogy is not canon anymore. They should try to keep that canon. Not unexpected when they announced the movies. Lucas pretty much canonized them since he didn't expect to do other movies. Disney showed him the money and changed everything. I think the writers of the EU got a little full of themselves when it was considered canon with characters being killed off. Now they are as equal to Star Trek novel writers. Can they make a good story that people will want to read without it being labeled as canon? |
All up to Disney really.
|
This does make me wonder if they will even bother to make any post-jedi EU stuff. Actually wouldn't mind if they didn't, as they've pretty much gotten all they could out of expanding on the films.
Now, after the new trilogy comes out, I'm sure there will be lots of EU expanding off of that, which of course will be non canon. |
Quote:
All writers are full of themselves. Ask Kalyx. |
Yeah it behooves us to believe our work the stuff of odysseys. Otherwise you're in the wrong field. An episode of Home Movies perfectly captures this in two cute scenes showing Brandon and his mom writing. You have to believe your shit is gold if you expect people to believe it silver at least.
|
As long as Greedo shooting first isn't cannon (and by extention, the hackmeat shoehorning of Slug Jabba/"spawnglitching" Solo in the hangar having exactly the same conversation with Han the freshly dead bounty hunter just had mostly BECAUSE this scene wasn't in the film), I dont really care.
All they basically did was give themselves licence to do just anout anything without having legions of fans bitching about how x scene didn't fit into the universe because of obscure novel or comic shit only the hardest of the hardcore even know about. The complaints start now, run its course, and die down instead of having the line form at the release of the finished film. |
The Greedo thing is such overblown bullshit.
|
Maybe. But to me, it wasn't so much rage that they couldn't just let Han be a scoundrel and morph it into "self defense" (although, it makes Greedo's aim worse than a Stormtroopers AND Han was supposed to be somewhat of a dirty cheater), it was the horrible editing job to shoehorn the extra gunshot in.
If Han Solo could teleport out of the way of a laser blast and back, why does he need to fly the Millenium Falcon or lack belief in The Force? |
That's what bothers me. Not that they edited it so that Han is defending himself, but that they edited it so badly. It's just really atrocious filmmaking from a technical standpoint, ignoring what it does to the characters.
|
Well yeah it's a horrible shot. He just shifts to the side. It's jarring.
From a character standpoint, either outcome works, imo. Han's the sort of guy that can go either way like that. |
From a character standpoint, though, it was pretty unneccessary. Like changing guns to walkies in E.T. unneccessary. It added nothing to either character, and it was a change just for the sake of changing things... and one that was piss-poor in execution.
|
Han shooting first because he's a scoundrel, or defending himself because he's experienced enough to see a shot coming; is not the same as cops nonsensically pointing walkie talkies at you. Note that I'm specifically talking about it character wise, not the damn execution.
|
The edit still looks like dogshit either way.
Honestly wish they would just release the original cuts of the first trilogy on Blu-ray. |
Lucasfilm announces all future Extended Universe stuff will be considered cannon as part of a new unification process for the new "story group" team at the studio.
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
I was saying, in the overall story of Star Wars, that it really didn't matter if Han shot first or not; though him shooting first did add just that bit of subtlety to the character, there were plenty of other times where his rougeish tendencies were on display. It wasn't in and of itself that earth shattering for all those that got vein-in-forehead outraged over it... ... but as such, it was an arbitrary and wholly unnecessary edit even if it were rendered flawlessly (which it obviously wasn't). The 4kidz-ing of E.T. was more a device I used to illustrate how dumb changing shit that was already established just for the sake of changing shit was. In short: it was a dumbass move in every way. It didn't have any "real" impact by chainging it, so it didn't need to be done, and it was made more insulting by the half-assed execution. |
Quote:
|
Can't wait until they write a Crisis on Two Earths crossover with the old EU.
|
Overall, this is a better situation than the New 52 thing.
|
Rollercoaster week for anti-EU fans.
Probably throwing fiestas after the announcement that all EU stuff will be abolished, only to be told a few days later that all future EU will be part of their precious canon. Wish I could see their smug faces. |
Arguments are utterly stupid anyway.
You can decide yourself what you feel is canon. You don't need announcements, no matter how official to tell you how you should enjoy a series. If you want to write your own story about Padme marrying chewbacca and having a bunch of wookie babies, and then treat it as canon in your own mind, then go ahead. George Lucas himself can't stop you. |
My question is a minor one, though: by "Clone Wars", are they including the Taratovsky shorts as well, or just the full on CG series?
|
So just the 6 (+ future) films and Clone Wars are canon now? None of even the LucasArts created stuff (games) are considered canon?
|
Yeah what a fucking mess wonder what the people still playing SWTOR think about this.
|
Still playing; it's not like their character was gonna get into a movie or show. Decent game is a decent game.
|
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:40 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin®