![]() |
best kubrick film
kubrick has become my favorite director over the years. i think what he did with films was completely beyond humanity's portrayal of filmmaking. i own all of his movies except for lolita, eyes wide shut, and his earlier stuff, and i love all of them. to spark debate about kubrick's wonderful body of work, i've made a poll of his movies. what's your favorite? what's his best?
i voted for 2001: a space odyssey. as memorable as clockwork orange and the shining were, and as fantastically-made as barry lyndon was, i think this is the peak of his career. it's a full-blown fuckin' orgasm all the way through, and it's just unbelievable to watch. however, it is a dedicated watch, so my favorite in terms of entertainment is probably the shining. i also love the way barry lyndon is made. |
This was really hard because it is so based on my mood. I really loved his version of "The Shining", but as a HUGE Stephen King fan I was a little disappointed that he made some major changes to the story.
I chose Full Metal Jacket, just because it is so powerful and I believe that it will be one of the movies that will never feel dated. |
2001, because it's the only one I've seen in it's entirety.
|
I've only seen 2001, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, and Dr. Strangelove.
|
A Clockwork Orange
|
Quote:
|
From best to least best, IMO:
A Clockwork Orange Full Metal Jacket Paths of Glory Eyes Wide Shut The Shining Dr. Strangelove 2001: A Space Odyssey Lolita Barry Lyndon The Killing Spartacus The Killer's Kiss |
Spartacus kicked ass, but it doesn't compare to A Clockwork Orange.
|
Clockverk
|
Oh yeah, I've seen Dr. Strangelove too. Didn't really "get it", I guess.
|
Strangelove.
|
Dr. Strangelove.
|
2001
Maybe this isn't the right place to state this, but I really found A Clockwork Orange to be completely overated. Granted, it was a good enough film, but I do not believe it was anything near as brilliant as a lot of people seem to claim. If anyone would like to debate it's merits further, I'd be interested in knowing why you found it so compelling. |
Clockwork Orange because it's the only Kubrick film I've seen lol
|
Quote:
My brain seems to be.... dying as of late. :-\ |
2001 and Full Metal Jacket. I chose 2001 as #1 simply because it is more original. Then The Shinning. After those, I guess Spartacus and Clockwork Orange would be next.
|
It's really a very difficult choice. I went with Spartacus, not really sure why, probably because I've seen it less than I've seen Full Metal Jacket, 2001, and The Shinning, so my memory may overrate it just a little.
I've never seen Clockwork Orange, but even without taking that into consideration, I believe that this is ultimately one of those polls where you really cannot fairly pass judgement on which is best; because each is going to have it's own unique aspects which make that respective film really great. |
From what I've seen, I'd say A Clockwork Orange.
|
Clockwork Orange was fucking great. So was FMJ. Had to flip a coin to decide.
|
Fuck this is hard. Probably Clockwork Orange though. The Shining comes in second.
|
I've only seen Full Metal Jacket and Eyes Wide Shut and FMJ was amazing so I went for that.
|
From best to least best, IMO:
A Clockwork Orange Full Metal Jacket Paths of Glory Dr. Strangelove The Shining 2001: A Space Odyssey Spartacus Eyes Wide Shut The Killing Barry Lyndon Haven't seen: Lolita The Killer's Kiss |
Quote:
|
i think clockwork orange is what everybody says. this poll supports that. although i think clockwork is an excellent movie, i don't think it's his best. there's something lacking to it; i think it's a little bit less focused than his other films. there are numerous scenes that i feel make the movie longer without necessarily adding to it.
also, it's his most commercial movie, so non-kubrick fans are just voting for it. space odyssey remains the best kubrick movie i've seen. |
A Clockwork Orange is amazing to me mostly due to how original it is. It is like, you have never and will never see anything like it again. Same goes for pretty much all his movies, but you know.
|
The fact that A Clockwork Orange is an amazing novel takes away some points for me. That may be unfair on my part, but I'm being honest.
Don't get me wrong it is a great movie and he did a great job, but Full Metal Jacket and Paths of Glory (which I'm surprised only got one vote) for me are his best. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I have ACO on tape, but I haven't watched it yet.
I'm gonna go for the Shining. He dared to be different from the book, and it worked. |
Anyway, the thing I like best about Kubrick is that he tried his hand at so many genres
|
A Clockwork Orange.
|
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:53 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin®