TPWW Forums

TPWW Forums (https://www.tpwwforums.com/index.php)
-   wrestling forum (https://www.tpwwforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   TPWW's Favorite Wrestler: Round 1 (https://www.tpwwforums.com/showthread.php?t=77879)

Destor 04-05-2008 08:31 AM

TPWW's Favorite Wrestler: Round 1
 
Alright, this is pretty self explanitory. Post Who you like better out of the match ups. In a week or so once people have stopped posting this will close and we'll move on to the next round. Like I said the brackets were decided by the votes a wrestler got in the nominations. Get to it.

1. Shawn Micheals vs Ultimo Dragon
2. Mr. Perfect vs Mickie James
3. Big Show vs Fit Finlay
4. Kurt Angle vs Ted DiBiase
5. Eddie Guerrero vs Ken Kennedy
6. Lance Storm vs Dean Malenko
7. Randy Orton vs AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit vs Takeshi Morishima
9. Undertaker vs John Cena
10. Sting vs Brock Lesnar
11. Raven vs Vader
12. HHH vs Smaoa Joe
13. Kevin Nash vs Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page vs. Amazing Kong
15. Scott Hall vs KENTA
16. Bret Hart vs Nigel McGuiness
17. Mic Foley vs Harley Race
18. MVP vs Arn Anderson
19. Taz vs Hulk Hogan
20. Ric Flair vs Rey Mysterio
21. The Ultimate Warrior vs Alex Shelly
22. Booker T vs Brian Pillman
23. Edge vs Jeff Hardy
24. Chris Jericho vs Sid Vicious
25. Ricky Steamboat vs Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart vs Bryan Danielson
27. Rob Van Dam vs Jushin Lyger
28. The Rock vs Trish Stratus
29. Randy Savage vs Alex Wright
30. Christian Cage vs Dusty Rhoades
31. CM Punk vs Kenta Kobashi
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs Tully Blanchard



Destor 04-05-2008 08:37 AM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Fit Finlay
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Brock Lesnar
11. Vader
12. HHH
13. Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. KENTA
16. Bret Hart
17. Harley Race
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Booker T
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Rick Rude
26. Bryan Danielson
27. Jushin Lyger
28. Trish Stratus
29. Randy Savage
30. Dusty Rhoades
31. CM Punk
32. Tully Blanchard

that Warrior match was hard for the wrong reasons...

The Fugitive 04-05-2008 09:16 AM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Fit Finlay
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Sting
11. Raven
12. HHH
13. Kevin Nash
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. KENTA
16. Bret Hart
17. Harley Race
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelley
22. Booker T
23. Jeff Hardy
24. Chris Jericho
25. Ricky Steamboat
26. Bryan Danielson
27. Jushin Lyger
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Blue Demon 04-05-2008 10:05 AM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Fit Finlay
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Dean Malenko
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Brock Lesnar
11. Raven
12. HHH
13. Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Harley Race
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. The Ultimate Warrior
22. Brian Pillman
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Ricky Steamboat
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Londoner 04-05-2008 11:00 AM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Brock Lesnar
11. Raven
12. HHH
13. Kevin Nash
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall(havent seen much of kenta)
16. Bret Hart
17. Mic Foley
18. MVP
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Booker T
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Ricky Steamboat
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

What Would Kevin Do? 04-05-2008 11:05 AM


1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Fit Finlay
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Dean Malenko
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Brock Lesnar
11. Vader
12. HHH
13. Kevin Nash
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. KENTA
16. Nigel McGuiness
17. Mic Foley
18. MVP
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Brian Pillman
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Rick Rude
26. Bryan Danielson
27. Jushin Lyger
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. Kenta Kobashi
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin



JH 04-05-2008 11:06 AM

1. Shawn Micheals vs Ultimo Dragon--hbk
2. Mr. Perfect vs Mickie James--hennig
3. Big Show vs Fit Finlay--show
4. Kurt Angle vs Ted DiBiase--angle
5. Eddie Guerrero vs Ken Kennedy--eddie
6. Lance Storm vs Dean Malenko--malenko
7. Randy Orton vs AJ Styles--aj
8. Chris Benoit vs Takeshi Morishima--benoit
9. Undertaker vs John Cena--cena
10. Sting vs Brock Lesnar--sting
11. Raven vs Vader--raven
12. HHH vs Smaoa Joe--joe
13. Kevin Nash vs Jake Roberts--roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page vs. Amazing Kong--ddp
15. Scott Hall vs KENTA--hall
16. Bret Hart vs Nigel McGuiness--bret
17. Mic Foley vs Harley Race--foley
18. MVP vs Arn Anderson--double a
19. Taz vs Hulk Hogan--taz...god i'd love to see taz cripple him lol
20. Ric Flair vs Rey Mysterio--flair
21. The Ultimate Warrior vs Alex Shelly--alex
22. Booker T vs Brian Pillman--book
23. Edge vs Jeff Hardy--hardy
24. Chris Jericho vs Sid Vicious--y2j
25. Ricky Steamboat vs Rick Rude--steamboat
26. Owen Hart vs Bryan Danielson--owen
27. Rob Van Dam vs Jushin Lyger--rvd
28. The Rock vs Trish Stratus--rock
29. Randy Savage vs Alex Wright--macho
30. Christian Cage vs Dusty Rhoades--dusty
31. CM Punk vs Kenta Kobashi--punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs Tully Blanchard--austin

Lock Jaw 04-05-2008 02:00 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Sting
11. Vader
12. HHH
13. Kevin Nash
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Mic Foley
18. Arn Anderson
19. Hulk Hogan
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Booker T
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Ricky Steamboat
26. Owen Hart
27. Jushin Lyger
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Tully Blanchard

Jeritron 04-05-2008 03:08 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. Randy Orton
8. Takeshi Morishima
9. Undertaker
10. Brock Lesnar
11. Raven
12. HHH
13. Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. KENTA
16. Bret Hart
17. Mic Foley
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Booker T
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Ricky Steamboat
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage (Only because I never liked Dusty)
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

HeartBreakMan2k 04-05-2008 03:14 PM

1. Shawn Micheals vs Ultimo Dragon
2. Mr. Perfect vs Mickie James
3. Big Show vs Fit Finlay
4. Kurt Angle vs Ted DiBiase
5. Eddie Guerrero vs Ken Kennedy
6. Lance Storm vs Dean Malenko
7. Randy Orton vs AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit vs Takeshi Morishima
9. Undertaker vs John Cena
10. Sting vs Brock Lesnar
11. Raven vs Vader
12. HHH vs Smaoa Joe
13. Kevin Nash vs Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page vs. Amazing Kong
15. Scott Hall vs KENTA
16. Bret Hart vs Nigel McGuiness
17. Mic Foley vs Harley Race
18. MVP vs Arn Anderson
19. Taz vs Hulk Hogan
20. Ric Flair vs Rey Mysterio
21. The Ultimate Warrior vs Alex Shelly
22. Booker T vs Brian Pillman
23. Edge vs Jeff Hardy
24. Chris Jericho vs Sid Vicious
25. Ricky Steamboat vs Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart vs Bryan Danielson
27. Rob Van Dam vs Jushin Lyger
28. The Rock vs Trish Stratus
29. Randy Savage vs Alex Wright
30. Christian Cage vs Dusty Rhoades
31. CM Punk vs Kenta Kobashi
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs Tully Blanchard

NoJabbaNoBogRoll 04-05-2008 03:26 PM

1. Shawn Micheals vs Ultimo Dragon
2. Mr. Perfect vs Mickie James
3. Big Show vs Fit Finlay
4. Kurt Angle vs Ted DiBiase
5. Eddie Guerrero vs Ken Kennedy
6. Lance Storm vs Dean Malenko
7. Randy Orton vs AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit vs Takeshi Morishima
9. Undertaker vs John Cena
10. Sting vs Brock Lesnar
11. Raven vs Vader
12. HHH vs Smaoa Joe
13. Kevin Nash vs Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page vs. Amazing Kong
15. Scott Hall vs KENTA
16. Bret Hart vs Nigel McGuiness
17. Mic Foley vs Harley Race
18. MVP vs Arn Anderson
19. Taz vs Hulk Hogan
20. Ric Flair vs Rey Mysterio
21. The Ultimate Warrior vs Alex Shelly
22. Booker T vs Brian Pillman
23. Edge vs Jeff Hardy
24. Chris Jericho vs Sid Vicious
25. Ricky Steamboat vs Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart vs Bryan Danielson
27. Rob Van Dam vs Jushin Lyger
28. The Rock vs Trish Stratus
29. Randy Savage vs Alex Wright
30. Christian Cage vs Dusty Rhoades
31. CM Punk vs Kenta Kobashi
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs Tully Blanchard

weather vane 04-05-2008 03:30 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Ted DiBiase
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Dean Malenko
7. AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Sting
11. Raven
12. HHH
13. Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Mic Foley
18. Arn Anderson
19. Hulk Hogan
20. Ric Flair
21. The Ultimate Warrior
22. Brian Pillman
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Dusty Rhoades
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Afterlife 04-05-2008 04:10 PM

1. Ultimo Dragon
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Sting
11. Vader
12. HHH
13. Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Nigel McGuiness
17. Mic Foley
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Rey Mysterio
21. Alex Shelly
22. Brian Pillman
23. Jeff Hardy
24. Chris Jericho
25. Ricky Steamboat
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Alex Wright
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

thedamndest 04-05-2008 04:22 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Ted DiBiase
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Sting
11. Vader
12. HHH
13. Kevin Nash
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Harley Race
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Booker T
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Dusty Rhoades
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

The Optimist 04-05-2008 06:03 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Dean Malenko
7. AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Sting
11. Raven
12. Triple H
13. Kevin Nash
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Mic Foley
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Ultimate Warrior
22. Booker T
23. Jeff Hardy
24. Jericho
25. Steamboat
26. Owen Hart
27. Jushin Thunder Liger hardest decision on the list
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Dusty Rhodes
31. Kenta Kobashi
32. Steve Austin

I'm suprised Amazing Kong got on the list and Roddy Piper didn't.

ddpBANG 04-05-2008 06:17 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Dean Malenko
7. Randy Orton
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Brock Lesnar
11. Raven
12. HHH
13. Kevin Nash
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Harley Race
18. MVP
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Brian Pillman
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Good Ol JG 04-05-2008 07:27 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Big Show
4. Kurt Angle
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Lance Storm
7. AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit
9. Undertaker
10. Brock Lesnar
11. Raven
12. Samoa Joe
13. Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Mick Foley
18. Arn Anderson
19. Taz
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelley
22. Brian Pillman
23. Edge
24. Chris Jericho
25. Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Tully Blanchard (had to give Tully a vote)

Porcupine 04-05-2008 08:49 PM

1. Shawn Micheals
- Didnt see enough of Ultimo, didnt see enough Charisma in him. Shawn is shawn.
2. Mr. Perfect
- Easy one here.
3. Big Show
- Like Big Show better as a total package.
4. Kurt Angle
- Angle is one of my top three or so.
5. Eddie Guerrero
- Another easy one.
6. Lance Storm
- Urgh. Two guys I'm really a fan of, but gotta go with Storm by just a little bit.
7. Randy Orton
- Two dicks. I choose the one that I watched/like more.
8. Takeshi Morishima
- Morishima is awesome for his size.
9. Undertaker
- Undertaker is another one of my top favs of all time.
10. Sting
- Sting did much more than Brock ever did. His work with Flair alone cements him here.
11. Raven
- Tough one. Will have to go with Raven for his promos.
12. HHH
- Small Joe! All kidding aside, HHH is more dimensional than Joe.
13. Kevin Nash
- Come on. Its Nash.
14. Diamond Dallas Page
- Was always a fan of DDP.
15. Scott Hall
- Did not see enough of KENTA.
16. Bret Hart
- Hart. Too many classic moments.
17. Mick Foley
- Foley. Another one of my top favs.
18. MVP
- MVP by just a notch...hope his potential turns out to be what it looks like.
19. Taz
- Giving the vote to Taz here because his ECW run is probably one of the best wrestling "pieces" of all time.
20. Ric Flair
- Flair is more dimensional. Rey lacks in Charisma area and isnt a good heel.
21. The Ultimate Warrior
- Squash!
22. Booker T
- Argh. Hate to vote against Pillman, but had more exposure to Booker and loved him all around.
23. Edge
- Jeff is not as good on the mic and screws it up for himself too much. Sorry Jeff.
24. Sid Vicious
- Because he has HALF THE BRAIN YOU DO!
25. Rick Rude
- A wrestler like Rick only comes once in a lifetime.
26. Owen Hart
- Owen. Bryan has yet to show me anything but awesome in ring skills. I like charisma too.
27. Rob Van Dam
- RVD. If only he didnt smoke pot so much.
28. The Rock
- Why are awesome women being pitted against legends? Sorry Trish.
29. Randy Savage
- OOH NO! His Rap album alone provided me with much entertainment. Poor Das Wunderkind.
30. Christian Cage
- Christian. Dusty never really impressed me. Maybe its because I mostly saw his crappy WWF run.
31. Kenta Kobashi
- Hard one, but I will go with Kenta.
32.Tully Blanchard
- Sympathy vote for Tully, once again because I only liked Austin as a heel. Hated, hated him as a face much like people dislike Cena in recent times.

CSL 04-06-2008 12:20 AM

1. Shawn Micheals
2. Mr. Perfect
3. Fit Finlay
4. Ted DiBiase
5. Eddie Guerrero
6. Dean Malenko
7. AJ Styles
8. Chris Benoit
9. John Cena
10. Sting
11. Vader
12. HHH
13. Jake Roberts
14. Diamond Dallas Page
15. Scott Hall
16. Bret Hart
17. Mic Foley
18. Arn Anderson
19. Hulk Hogan
20. Ric Flair
21. Alex Shelly
22. Brian Pillman
23. Jeff Hardy
24. Chris Jericho
25. Rick Rude
26. Owen Hart
27. Rob Van Dam
28. The Rock
29. Randy Savage
30. Christian Cage
31. CM Punk
32. Stone Cold Steve Austin

KENTA/Hall, Malenko/Storm and Angle/DiBiase were just mean

Destor 04-06-2008 12:24 AM

Well to be fair I didn't make the brakets, you all did. This was done by seeding based on who got the most votes in the nominations. for example HBK got the most votes, because of this he got the person with the least votes (or one of them anyway) Ultimo Dragon.

while I'm on the subject does anyone think I should continue this as a tournement, meaning these are the brackets and the wil face the winner of the match below them, or should I keep seeding? Meaning who ever gets the most votes would vate the guy who got the least?

Dunno.

Jeritron 04-06-2008 12:27 AM

Sounds about right. You've done it for one round so you should just keep it that way until it gets narrowed down to 2 I suppose. Then obviously the poll vote would decide...or, just a thought, once it gets down to 4 you could have a poll with 4 choices which would make things interesting, since it wouldn't be a choice between A and B

CSL 04-06-2008 12:34 AM

I would randomize.

Also, how the hell did Big Show get seeded 3rd? Some people must really hate Floyd Mayweather

Destor 04-06-2008 12:34 AM

Keep it which way? Seeding? I mean really this thing just started so theres no standerd set yet. Doing the seeding to decide who goes in the tournament makes sense but looking at it the top half is going to be stacked. If I went with the seeding that means the quality bouts wouldn't happen until much later. We'd get a few, but they would be more rare.

They both have their negatives...

Destor 04-06-2008 12:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CSLi Manning (Post 2108220)
I would randomize.

Also, how the hell did Big Show get seeded 3rd? Some people must really hate Flotd Mayweather

to keep the top half of the brakect from just being insane I put the second seed at the very bottom (SCSA) and then the thrid in the fourth match, the 4th in the 28th match. Etc by 4 so that the top guys guys would be seperated from one another. It made sense to me.

Destor 04-06-2008 12:37 AM

If anyones currious:

1.HBM 23
2.SCSA 15
3.Rock 15
4.Angle 14
5.Benoit 13
6.Jericho 13
7.HHH 13
8.Flair 12
9.Bret Hart 11
10.Perfect 11
11.Punk 10
12.Eddie 10
13.RVD 10
14.Undertaker 10
15.Edge 7
16.Kevin Nash 7
17.Taz 7
18.Foley 6
19.Big Show 5
20.Christian 5
21.Storm 5
22Owen Hart 5
23.Sting 5
24.Booker T 4
25.DDP 4
26.MVP 4
27.Orton 4
28.Savage 4
29.Raven 4
30.Steamboat 4
31.Hall 4
32.Warrior 4
33.Shelly 3
34.KENTA 3
35.Rude 3
36.Vader 3
37.Alex Wright 2
38.AJ 2
39.Arn Anderson 2
40.Kong 2
41.Pillman 2
42. Lesnar 2
43.Danielson 2
44.Malenko 2
45.Rhodes 2
46.Finlay 2
47.Race 2
48.Hogan 2
49.Jake roberts 2
50.Jeff hardy
51. Cena
52.Lyger 2
53.Kennedy 2
54.Kobashi 2
55.Mickie 2
56.McGuiness 2
57.Mysterio 2
58.Joe 2
59.Sid 2
60.Morishima 2
61.diBiase 2
62.Trish 2
63.tully 2
64. Ultimo 2

Jeritron 04-06-2008 12:42 AM

Jeff Hardy and Cena got 2 votes each, or none?

Destor 04-06-2008 12:43 AM

2 After you do so many it just bleeds together.

You still didn't answer my question though.

Jeritron 04-06-2008 12:44 AM

What was that?

Jeritron 04-06-2008 12:45 AM

Oh yea, I'd keep it seeding based on votes up until the end. Then either go with a 4 way poll or a 1 on 1 poll

Afterlife 04-06-2008 12:45 AM

Mickie. That's so ridiculous.

Jeritron 04-06-2008 12:45 AM

That's just my 2 cents, you can do it how you'd like. I just think since you've started that way it should continue and it seems the most fair and efficient way to do the matchups

Jeritron 04-06-2008 12:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Afterlife (Post 2108231)
Mickie. That's so ridiculous.

Why? I guess I see where you're coming from but she's a woman wrestler and that makes her a wrestler. You can't judge her on the same level as Flair or HBM, just as a woman wrestler. And as that her and Trish are pretty much the best. As ludicrous as it sounds, Trish would be like the Ric Flair of Women's wrestling. Again, sounds ridiculous but it's true when you look at it logically

Destor 04-06-2008 12:49 AM

*Megumi Kudo

Jeritron 04-06-2008 12:54 AM

When's Trish going into the WWE hall of fame? Or when is she coming back?

Afterlife 04-06-2008 12:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeritron (Post 2108233)
Why? I guess I see where you're coming from but she's a woman wrestler and that makes her a wrestler. You can't judge her on the same level as Flair or HBM, just as a woman wrestler. And as that her and Trish are pretty much the best. As ludicrous as it sounds, Trish would be like the Ric Flair of Women's wrestling. Again, sounds ridiculous but it's true when you look at it logically

Yes, they are in different catgories. That is why the comparrison is ridiculous.

Destor 04-06-2008 12:57 AM

I don't think shes going to come back tbh. she's achieved all she can and anything she were to do people would just say "well she's really gone down hill," etc. she got out at the right for the sake of her legacy. As far as the HoF I'd imagine they keep her out for the next 5-10 years as I'm sure they are hoping she comes back, and once your in the HoF its pretty final.

if she's smart she'll stay out, but for my sake I hope she comes back next Monday. or any Monday. Her call.

Destor 04-06-2008 01:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Afterlife (Post 2108238)
Yes, they are in different catgories. That is why the comparrison is ridiculous.

Not in my eyes, but I'm not sexist when itcomes to wrestling. (Ironically I am sexist is every other facet of life.) But don't blame me, It's not like I can put in any one person on my own. People were free to vote for who ever they thought deserved to be in. 3 of which are women.

Jeritron 04-06-2008 01:01 AM

No. They are all wrestlers. They can't be held to the same standards as a male wrestler, but can be judged at how good they are at what they do. Thus, they can be compared for the purposes of this poll.

For example, CM Punk is obviously better than Trish Stratus if you watched their work as stick figures or something. However, Trish Stratus is the greatest of her kind. Just like The Big Show or Undertaker as big men are better than Khali or Test.

Jeritron 04-06-2008 01:02 AM

It's hard to explain what I'm saying to you, since if you don't get it from my first explanation you prob never will. Destor knows what I'm talkin bout

Destor 04-06-2008 01:06 AM

Oh yeah. It's that very mind set that Afterlife has that leads a large part of the IWC to hate all big men or brawlers. they judge all good wrestling on one set scale instead judging whos better at their stlye. (Not saying Afterlife does this just saying that his inability to judge women with men is the same.)


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:19 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®