Regardless of what it says, don't TAP X. Wait until the dot is in the blue field and then press X a single time. Just a press, not a fast tapping contest. If you do it at the right time, you'll break the hold.
My problem is knocking people out with it. It seems like it's random or something. I've beaten people down all into complete and total red, and somehow they still manage to get out at the third arm drop, sometimes the first or second. THAT pisses me off more than anything. I eventually always beat them with it though, if it pisses me off enough (won't take no for an answer

).