I remember watching the 1992 RR and was thinking "oh boy. Hogan's gonna win it." When Sid Justice eliminated Hogan and then Flair eliminated Sid to win, it was one of the few times my eyes were wide open and jaw just dropping.
It was one of those things you just couldn't expect to happen back in those days.
And I see the Big Show is the only superstar who made it to the "final two" more than once and not winning.