Garrard... 64% comp. pct., 7.7 yds per attempt (.2 less than Peyton Manning), 18 TDs and 3 picks through 15 games while leading his team to an 11-4 record including a 3 point loss AT Indy where he completed 24 of 29 passes for 257 yds, 2 TDs and 1 pick. Just for fun, I'll throw in the fact that his QB rating is 4 points better than Peyton Manning's.
But let's disregard all that and just look at the fact that he only has a little over a TD per game... yeah, he sucks.