Music is opinionated. Another mans trash another mans gold. I listened to the SFTD and thought it was absolutely horrible. Its just that I think there are some people who can scream and make it sound good (Killswitch Engage, Soilwork, Corey Taylor in 30/30-150) and people who can be laid back and sing good (sometimes Paige Hamilton). While others, like Josh, just suck at it. Bottom line, I'm not a fan of QOTSA. And Josh said it in the the video "You fucking 12 year old....."