|
Theres a big difference between the type of movie you're suggesting, compared to the type of movie this is. They're different types of movies, rather than one of them being poorly executed.
For example:
Jerry McGuire. It uses fake athletes to tell a fictional story set in a realistic sports world
Bull Durham. Same
Almost Famous. Same, only with music.
Movies set in the filmmaking industry, like Tropic Thunder, Be Cool, Adaptation.
There are countless other examples of movies like this, that are in the setting and world, but use purely fictional characters, stories and other details to serve as a way to give an overall depiction. They're all based in truth.
Then you have movies that may use a fictional character or story, but use real names or events from it's setting:
At the moment I can't really think of any, but I'm sure you know what I'm talking about.
Curb Your Enthusiasm is sort of an example.
Like in Knocked Up. They have the fictional character played by Katherine Heigl work at E!, and you see Ryan Seacrest and other celbrities as themselves in a realistic environment.
Would this be any worse or flawed if it were a charicature of the setting with actors playing fake celbrities and the network being called Z!, or something like that? The audience gets the point, and for all intents and purposes, it accomplishes the same thing.
Sure one's more authentic, but it isn't neccesarrilly any more valid or convincing.
I know this a comedy, but its the same basic idea.
The same goes for books.
Last edited by Jeritron; 09-17-2008 at 04:48 PM.
|