Quote:
Originally Posted by Hanso
The ash maybe didnt keep things in the cabin but rather out....then somehow the ashes were broken, and smokey moved into the cabin to pretend to be jacob to Ben and falsely lead the others.
|
We actually have not had any evidence where we saw or it was suggested that The Others were ever deceived by the MIB. Jacob only spoke to Richard, probably in his statue chamber.
That's the thing, only Locke and a small other handful of people were under the impression it was Jacob in the cabin. And those people were not any of The Others, just the losties.