Well with good in-ring wrestlers, you can book things liike Iron Man matches or submissions matches. I'd also like the times of each segment to be included, so I'd be more inclined to rank Chris Sabin and Evan Bourne for fifteen minutes highter than The Great Khali and Mark Henry....unless you describe enough interesting things going on in the match.
Anyway, that's all pretty subjective. Here's a sample that Paul Heyman (thanks) has provided me with from a similar game:
http://altfeds.freeforums.org/wcw-ni...nings-t16.html
Now, that show goes into EXTREME detail, which is nice, but I don't think it's NECESSARY. Basically I want the bookers to write as much as they think they need to write to get their points across. I do like the touch of using the announcers at the beginning to set up the show and remind people of ongoing storylines, but again, that's not completely necessary. I also fear that something like that may the the "tl:dr" treatment from the public poll, but I trust at least the judges would get through it.
I'll try to find some alternatives to show you as well.