| The Excellence of Execution | 10  |
| Defeat 50 opponents using pin combination grapple moves (Offline). |
| Caught Slipping | 10 |
| Win a match in which you successfully use a leverage pin (Offline). |
| Power Of The Punch | 10 |
| Win a match in which you successfully KO an opponent using a strong strike (Offline). |
| Backstage Fisticuffs | 10 |
| During a backstage brawl, string 3 environmental grapple combos in succession (Offline). |
| Talk About Resilient | 20 |
| Kick out of The Undertaker's Tombstone Piledriver finisher on Legend difficulty (Offline). |
| For Whom the Bell Tolls | 20 |
| Pin or submit Undertaker in the WrestleMania arena on Legend difficulty (Offline). |
| Thank You Shawn | 20 |
| Defeat Shawn Michaels in the WrestleMania arena on Legend difficulty as Undertaker (Offline). |
| THQ Storytellers | 10 |
| Create a story in Story Designer with at least 2 moments. |
| Streak Breaker | 50 |
| Complete the Vs. Undertaker Road to WrestleMania story on any difficulty. |
| Randy's Fired | 50 |
| Complete John Cena's Road to WrestleMania story on any difficulty. |
| Runaway Champ | 50 |
| Complete Chris Jericho's Road to WrestleMania story on any difficulty. |
| 5-Second Pose | 50 |
| Complete Christian's Road to WrestleMania story on any difficulty. |
| No More Mystery, Yo | 50 |
| Complete Rey Mysterio's Road to WrestleMania story on any difficulty. |
| Champion of Champions | 50 |
| Using a created character, hold either the WWE or World Heavyweight title (Offline). |
| US Champ | 10 |
| Using a created character, win the United States Championship in WWE Universe (Offline). |
| Intercontinental Champ | 10 |
| Win the Intercontinental Championship in WWE Universe using a created character (Offline). |
| Unified Tag Champs | 10 |
| Win the Unified Tag Team titles in WWE Universe using a created character (Offline). |
| Mr. Money in the Bank | 50 |
| Win the Money In The Bank match in WWE Universe using a created character (Offline). |
| A Successful Cash In | 20 |
| Cash in Money In The Bank in WWE Universe and win using a created character (Offline). |
| A Student Of The Game | 10 |
| Complete 50% of the tips in the Practice Arena. |
| Magna Cum Laude | 50 |
| Complete all of the tips in the Practice Arena. |
| The Last Man Standing | 100 |
| Win a Royal Rumble match on Xbox LIVE. |
| Way To Contribute | 10 |
| Upload at least one item of created content to each category of Community Creations. |
|
|
|
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 100 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 20 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 20 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 50 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 10 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |
| Secret Achievement | 20 |
| Continue playing to unlock this secret achievement. |