I'm a Cards fan, but as much as I
Pujols, I'd have to say A-Rod. Pujols has had a better start to his career, but you gotta go with a SS/3B over 1B/3B/LF, especially when he hits as well as A-Rod... Cause you can always find a good 1B or LF to go with A-Rod, but if you take Pujols, can you get another good SS?