List as often as you wish, and feel free to give reasons why.
As of 01/13/12:
1) CM Punk - Still continues to be a "breath of fresh air" to me in the ME scene, and puts on great matches each week.
2) Randy Orton - (even though he was just recently hurt) Pretty much a 1A, but Punk is more fun to watch right now. Always puts on great matches.
3) Dolph Ziggler - On fire recently. The only thing he was missing was decent mic skills, and he's improved greatly with them.
4) Big Show - So underrated and I really enjoyed his feud with Henry.
5) Mark Henry - " " (except not quite underrated).