I voted for Kurt Angle. He barely beat out Eddie Guerrero though. They are both great wrestlers, both awesome on the mic, and both can draw a large number of fans. However, I chose Angle to break the tie because he can actually change between heel and face, whereas Eddie would probably not succeed as a heel anymore since he would get cheered too much. I also like Angle's wrestling style a little bit more, the amateur background that he has is great.
And come on, he won two gold medals with a broken freakin' neck!!!