Quote:
Originally Posted by #1-wwf-fan
I value a QB who can help and at times carry his team to wins. Tebow was fucking abysmal and managed to get some wins late to win his division with an 8-8 record. Something Manning did a shitload of times. And I'm pretty sure he was regularly winning 12+ games in doing so. With a shitty defense for most of that time. Putting up record breaking numbers. While Tebow was struggling to put up over 100 yards and hit 50% of his passes. Are you really trying to act like Tebow with is more of a winner and has proven more than Peyton fucking Manning? Really?
|
Peyton Manning won his only superbowl when the colts defense caught fire and channeled the 85 Chicago Bears. During that game, he was as pedestrian as ever, completing only one pass of consequence, the bomb to Reggie Wayne, while he completed over 10 passes to Joseph Addai, who also was part of a running back tandem that touched the ball 40 fucking times. Add the fact that Bob Sanders played out of his mind during that playoff run. and Freeny & Co lost his mind in the Superbowl...Hey I can't take the fact that he won one title from him. But, you can't deny that his SB win over the Bears featured one of the safest game plans of his career as well. Oddly enough, Tebows PLAYOFF winning percentage is better at .500 than Manning's, and they both have the same amount of game winning PLAYOFF Drives under their belt. I don't think Tim Tebow is the best Quarterback ever, but I do think that Peyton Manning is a sham of a quarterback. He's literally the opposite of Tebow, he'll throw the ball around amassing statistics and wowing the masses for 58 minutes...but when the chips are down you can count on a game clinching Interception IN THE PLAYOFFS.
Again, I'm not fooled by the fools gold of the regular season. I could care less about how he routinely goes 10-0 13-0 when his lasting memories are of him dejected, watching some cornerback shuffle into the endzone after picking him off to end his season. Ryan Clark, Ty Law (a million times) that guy from Nawlins...
Quote:
Originally Posted by #1-wwf-fan
The guy can't even push Mark Sanchez out of a job for fuck's sake!
|
Tebow earned a shot at being quarterback for the broncos by resurrecting what was sure to be a sorry assed season last year and throwing for 300 plus yards and a game winning touchdown against the Steelers. Honestly though, this is more of an indictment against Manning than a 'vote of confidence' for Tebow. Peyton Manning's numerous clutch failures in college and the NFL should have been evidence that this is NOT the guy to waste two years around. hell the guy can't even properly groom a replacement. Is Curtis Painter doing anything right now? How do you think Peyton will do grooming his replacement in Denver? I don't see another Andrew Luck coming to bail a franchise out of the black hole that is Manning.
Quote:
Originally Posted by #1-wwf-fan
Oh and Tebow didn't go 7-2 last year in the regular season. He went 6-4.
|
This is true. I couldn't remember that reccord at the moment of the post. Thanks for the factual update.
