I voted Dawn Marie Psaltis because I like my chicks with a few more wrinkles (but not Mae Young-level folds). DMP would probably buy me a treat and make some delicious casserole!
The smoker's wrinkles make her look more honest, IMHO. If a smoker, then a little airing out fixes smoker's breath. I'm sure Velvet will look even better when older, but for now I vote Dawn Marie.