|
|
My review c&p'd from the movie thread.
Man of Steele-5/10
Immensely disappointing. Wasn't anywhere near the film it could have been.
Story was way too rushed. They spent time marketing this as a film that would delve into Clark's emotions as an outcast and someone who, despite being an extraordinary being, was held back to being ordinary by a cautious father who was both scared of what the world would do if they knew his son's true capabilities, but was hopeful that whatever Clark was, wherever he came from, he was there to be something important.
Instead, we only get glimpses of what was an excellent yet short lived performances from Costner going over what essentially amounts to bullet points in Clark's past. These scenes are, far and away more interesting than any other in the entire film. And they are, unfortunately, glossed over as flash backs. They are also the most development Clark gets in the entire film. Adult Clark, unlike, say adult Bruce Wayne, goes through no transition character wise.
For a few scenes, with little dialogue, we see what Clark is up to, then, randomly, he stumbles onto hearing the location of some ship, which ends of being the Fortress of Solitude. He, rather flatly, is told of who he really is, where he came from, and is randomly given the suit and cape from his father's ghost, and bam, he's all of sudden flying around in costume. Literally no build up, whatsoever. It's just "Hey, I infiltrated this Kyptonian space craft the military found, found out who I was, and now I'm geared up, ready to accept my destiny".
Zod could have been a great villian, but he's squandered to not enough dialogue scenes exploring his character and is an otherwise forgettable punching bag for Superman. There's a line before the final bang zoom fight scene that Zod states, and it sums up his character beautifully. Unfortunately, prior to that line, he's not given much time to expand on his feelings and justifications.
And while still on Zod, why in God's name would he be banished to the Phantom Zone when A) everyone including the Council knew Krypton was going to blow, which would B) free Zod and his minions upon doing so. Just poor writing there.
Lois Lane wasn't bad, but again, another character who wasn't given enough time and was seemingly thrust into being in love with Superman for the sake of it. The two characters didn't share much pre disaster screen time for this to work properly.
And man, did the action drag on way to long. It was so over the top and ridiculous that, honestly, it took me out of the film. I was not interested in any of these fights, especially because Clark could legitimately hold his own with these genetically created warriors. Faora and Zod both mention they were created for this sole purpose, yet Supes, with zero formal training at all, hangs with and ultimately defeats them.
Ultimately, just a huge let down here. It felt like Zach Snyder couldn't get away from rushing into the loud madness of the action scenes, and short changed the most interesting aspect of the film. Meh.
To add onto this, I was just really underwhelmed with the whole thing. I don't think this is a bad movie. But it's not a good movie, either. It's, at the end of the day, a mediocre film. I cannot see this film, in, 8 years, being looked at like Batman Begins or Iron Man as films that, in different ways as different films, were so good and well done that they reinvigorated the character, emotionally and as a tangible person. This film doesn't do this. Destroyer made a few points that I, per the review, completely agree with. Also, I agree with El Vaquero that that the fall of Krypton opening was really well done. It just got really choppy, clunky, and eventually rushed from there.
One more gripe before I go...
Before Superman breaks Zod's neck, Zod is using heat vision to corner civilians in a museum, and tells Clark a line that starts "If you really love these people...", which, given the story's insistence that Clark was a reject, that he was bullied and not allowed to stand up for himself, that he was held back from being who he really was in fear of worldly rejection, would lead you to ask, why would he love those people? What have they showed him, at any time in his life, to merit his unconditional trust?
Yes, there's the scene where the priest tells him the leap of faith comes first, then trust. But after that brief talk, there's absolutely no play on being conflicted and not trusting. Another angle, imo, that was wasted here.
|