Quote:
Originally Posted by James Steele
I'm not disagreeing that Tom Brady isn't one of the greatest of all time, but to dismiss Payton Manning's career as anything but great is fucking ridiculous and not plausible unless you are a dumbass.
|
In the following post I made a couple of pages back, I acknowledge that peyton is a great quarterback.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Krimzon7
Most QB's would. Let's talk about Peyton right now...He'd Kill to be his 'lesser' brother Eli right now, with his two championships and everything.
And I'm not saying Peyton isn't good. Hell, I'll even call him great. But the greatest? He's not the greatest of our generation. He's definitely not the greatest of all time.
Can you tell me how yards Johnny Unitas threw for? How about Bart Star? What about Joe Montanna? How many yards did Fat Ben Roethlisberger throw for? How many yards or touch downs or first downs has Tom Brady Thrown for? Otto Graham? Let's get a little more local. How many records do Troy Aikman or Roger Staubach have right now?
You people want to quantify greatness in bullshit records that are broken every year as seasons are lengthened, and rules are geared towards passing.
The one thing that will make a quarterback immortal is Championship titles. Wake up, stop being mindless drones swallowing the goup that people tell you make somebody great.
|