No "Jumping" Jeff Farmer?
Seriously, I'd go with this...
50. Edge
49. Mr. Ron Wright
48. Bray Wyatt
47. Shane McMahon
46. Lanny Poffo
45. Stephanie McMahon
44. Shawn Michaels
43. Austin Idol
42. New Jack
41. Jimmy Valiant
40. Dutch Mantell (I know Zeb Coulter is his WWE name, but fuck that, I'm going with Dutch.)
39. Triple H
38. The Grand Wizard of Wrestling
37. JBL
36. Brian Pillman
35. Thunderbolt Patterson
34. Kevin Sullivan
33. William Regal
32. Ernie Ladd
31. Kurt Angle
30. Rick Rude
29. Gary Hart
28. Nick Bockwinkel
27. Jesse Ventura
26. The Million Dollar Man
25. Terry Funk
24. Chris Jericho
23. Michael P.S. Hayes
22. Raven
21. Captain Lou Albano
20. John Cena
19. Jerry Lawler
18. Hulk Hogan
17. Harley Race
16. Arn Anderson
15. Superstar Billy Graham
14. CM Punk
13. Mr. McMahon
12. Jim Cornette
11. Macho Man Randy Savage
10. Jake Roberts
9. Dusty Rhodes
8. Jackie Fargo
7. Bobby The Brain Heenan
6. Mick Foley
5. Paul Heyman
4. Stone Cold Steve Austin
3. Roddy Piper
2. Ric Flair
1. The Rock