|
I think most of them are spot-on. There's definitely a bit of recentism bias as per usual when things like this are done but most are probably justifiable. Ex: for the Giants I really don't know how you leave off a guy like Juan Marichal...but Posey's been a centerpiece to 3 titles in the last 5 years so it's understandable that he won the vote.
Feel like Pujols would have made it for the Cards if he was still playing there now, although I have no idea which of those 4 guys you'd take off.
The Rays list is kinda hilarious to look at. That being said I have no idea how you leave off Carl Crawford who still holds many of their offensive records.
|