Brock wins and it's not even close, albeit mostly based on his 2002-2004 run. The man tore through the roster from the get-go, dominated the 2002 KotR, beat Rock for the belt @ SummerSlam that year, and was mostly unstoppable. He had an epic match with Kurt @ WM XIX and also against Eddie @ No Way Out 2004...he actually looked strong in defeat there.
Rey on the other hand feels like he has had some feel-good underdog moments, but only moments. There aren't any matches of his that I recall standing out and really wowing me.
For those reasons, I voted Brock.
|