Well I voted for one of my personal all-time favorite wrestling games and that is Wrestlefest:The Arcade Game. This game was the greatest back in the day and it was the only game I played when I went to the arcade.
This game had a great Royal Rumble match with 6 or 8 guys on a screen at once. The Rumble was so much fun and I think it was a lot better then the Smackdown games Royal Rumble's.
You could choose from 12 WWF superstars like Hogan, Warrior, Perfect, Jake, Demolition and more. There was also interviews with Mene Gene before the match and entrances for each superstar. I'm not sure if they had their real themes play while they came out though. But Demolition's entrance with the masks and their costumes was priceless. Steel Cage was also a match in the game too.
Here are some pics to bring back the memories:
