yes, my kind of thread. I wanna create every single baseball team's all-time roster, but I'll just do my own
and wtf? Mattewson on the Reds? He played like a game for them. And I would definately add Joe Jackson to that Sox lineup
Anyway: Yankees
Lineup:
Jeter: SS
Lazzeri: 2B
Gehrig: 1B
Ruth: RF
Jackson: DH
Mantle: CF
DiMaggio: LF
3B: Dugan (if A-Rod plays at least 5 yrs, switch to him)
C: Dickey (fuck Berra)
Bench:
Mattingly: 1B

Berra: C
Meusel: OF
Winfield: OF
Munson: C (two catchers, but I can't leave him out)
Rizzuto: SS
Keeler/Willams: OF
Nettles: 3B
Randolph: 2B
Starters not in any order. fuck, this is gonna be impossible to pick 5
Ford
Ruffing
Gomez
Hoyt
Pettite
Pennock: Had to add him
Didn't add Hunter and Clemens because I just see them on the A's and Sox respectively.
Rivera
Gossage
Guidry
Chesbro
Righetti