Quote:
|
Originally Posted by VonErich Lives
Ok, let's get RP going again...
The old Montana v. Marino question.
You're building a team, your starting QB either Brady or Manning, who do you take?
|
Manning. You give him a genius as his coach, we'll see what happens. The Colts throw three plays in to Manning and let him audible. If he had a Brian Billick type OC, could you imagine what he would be capable of?
Or, say, he had a coach/defense like they have in New England?
Also, who was it... Connie Mack? OR some other old-time manager in MLB, formulated that it is better to have a perenniel competitive team who folds in the end, than to have a Championship-caliber team, because if a team wins it all, their players' stock rises (see Dwight Smith, and all of the Baltimore Ravens players of 2000), and if they put up stats and wins, but always fall short -- they'll still have fans holding out hope.
From a business stand-point, I'd say Manning. Manning played well on HORRIBLE teams. We don't know what Brady would/could do without the Pats.