AJ.
Both are good wrestlers overall but AJ takes the nod mainly because of her career being a lot more successful on the main roster than Emma. Also for her playing a big role in WWE eventually taking women's wrestling more seriously with NXT and her acting as the bridge for it.
Could argue Emma is easily the biggest botched call-up on the women's side since modern NXT started. A lot of potential squandered because the WWE has no clue what to do for her for any periods of time.
|