Lost: Season 3

[Avenger]

Originally Posted by Jon Kano See how hard was that? Again, its not that conclusive. Unless I see it on the Fuselage or something, or the episode that concludes otherwise, its all fanbased theory. I just think the excuse 'an effect gone wrong' is false, since so much money, time and talent goes into the show, they wouldn't include it if they were not happy with it or what it would resonate in the future. Like I said, its a controlled entity, a piece of debris wouldn;t fly/fall like that.

1) The theory that that is the monster is also fan-based as the producers have said nothing about it

2) This is most likely to have happened as it was in a pilot episode which is usually rushed and careless

3) They make it up AS THEY GO ALONG! Think they planned as far back as the first ep that the monster was black smoke?

4) LOL Lost isn't real!