In 2013, how important is a guy's finisher?

[Keith]

Originally Posted by Keith Watching that, it still boggles the mind why Randy Orton isn't an even bigger star.

So my question still stands, still boggles my mind.

Orton has achieved a lot. He's won many titles. He's been a headliner. He's been pushed as a face, he's been pushed as a heel. He seems to be over with the fans regardless of him being face or heel. He's got good wrestling ability.

I still can't understand why he's not an even bigger star.