The only scenario I can think of that would regain her momentum after that tap out, is if she lobbies backstage to get in the Rumble and they say " ok, you gotta go in as #1 " and she does and she wins it from #1.
I don't think anyone's ever winning from #1 again.
"HE/SHE IS THE FIRST PERSON TO WIN FROM NUMBER 1 SINCE..........never mind"