LOST Theories (will have spoliers)

[Buzzkill]

Originally Posted by Jon Kano Na man, not got it wrong... Them on the beach (The Incident, season 5) was def before when they sat on the log with the bottle of wine (Ab Aeterno, season 6). It was NOT the french people. They came after. But yeah, I consider the whole dark and stormy vs daylight and calm thing a big fuck up. I think they decided as they got to that point that they would change it and have the ship destroy the statue - I mean everyone was saying it was 'days away from the Island still' - fuck off it's as clear as daylight how close it is, a mile or two at the most. And a wooden ship up against dense stone statue, and the statue falls? come on!

Pretty sure it was the 1,000,000 tons of water that destroyed the statue, not the wooden ship.

And as we've seen in the Lost universe, the weather can change very, very, very quickly

[Jon Kano]

Originally Posted by Buzzkill Pretty sure it was the 1,000,000 tons of water that destroyed the statue, not the wooden ship. And as we've seen in the Lost universe, the weather can change very, very, very quickly

They still made the point that the ship hit it and it was destroyed, and even so...the force and power of 1,000,000 tons of water pushing a wooden ship into thick stone...the ship ending up about as wrecked as it would've been if it was just in the ocean?... would be like throwing a beer bottle at a wall. But still I guess I'm nip picking, yet it is one of the answers I wasn't so impressed with.