Would you put them in the HOF?
 

There's a lot of talk about people being "Hall of Fame" worthy. A common quote is that "if Koko's in, you might as well put them in" but I'm coming at this from a different angle.

I'm talking about the likes of Scott Hall (alcoholic) and Jake Roberts (drug addict). Would putting guys like that in the HOF be a public relations faux pas?

I know this sounds terrible, but I can see guys like that going in posthumously. It may be terrible PR to put the dregs of the earth in the HOF while they're living, but "honoring a fallen friend" would actually go over well.

Why not? it's after their careers were over.

Scott Hall still has some influence on the youngsters... check this out
<object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/DiNCPNNC3Zo?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/DiNCPNNC3Zo?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>

Time heals all wounds. Jake Roberts I could see any time. Scott Hall... give it about 10 years.

Oh wait, you mean the WWE Hall of Fame?

















































Nevermind

Good one, dhellova guy.

I've always felt about sports in general that a guy should be deemed on his contribution to the sport and not his personal character. Yeah Scott and Jake have their own personal demons, but that doesn't take away from what they did in the ring.

The only exception would have to be for rapists and murderers. In those cases, those guys impacted/ altered another human beings life in a way that should never be forgiven and they deserve to die not be praised or honored.

I would put Jake Roberts in there he was good at his craft.

Funny you should mention that. I started thinking about the subject after hearing that Jerry Lawler had been accused of raping and sodomizing a minor (which ended up being lies).

So I guess New Jack's out........

What about Gypsy Joe and New Jack at the same time?

I don't know he no sold everything New Jack did to him.

Eddie Guerrero was a druggie, so whats the harm in throwing a few more smackheads in there?

When Eddie went in he wasn't a druggie anymore.

Scott used to be buddy buddy with HHH so I think he could have a good chance if they still are...
Jake, maybe if he was asked.

:y: I am in complete agreement. Jake more than deserves to be in. I remember JR saying something along the lines Jake not having the greatest of bodies, or being the most athletically gifted guy, but had the ability to really tell a story on the mic and through in ring psychology. That's a gift and a half. I'm inclined to say you could learn a lot from watching Jake Roberts in his prime.

I think they both should be in ...especially Jake Roberts Though i think there may be others who deserve to be in too(savage) Roberts is near top of the list...scott Hall... more at the near bottom,maybe he n Kevin Nash will get in together?

Not just Roberts/Hall, what others might be considered risky to go in?

Yea, definately. I can really hold drugs against those guys going into the HOF since the HOF is filled with wrestlers that abused drugs. Roddy Piper, Iron Shiek, Jimmy Snuka etc... They've all had thier issues. Hall and Roberts are just unfortunately always in the public eye about it.

Personally being in the WWE Hall holds no real honor. The only people who get in now are those that Vinnie deems worthy, with that being said.

I don't think Scott Hall has done enough in his career to warrant being in any Hall of Fame, except maybe an AWA HoF. Jake the Snake on the other hand was not only excellent in the ring, but his stick work was bar none. Very few could use their promos to tell a story and set the stage like Jake the Snake. Plus he created the DDT.

Forget Scott Hall, Forget Jake the Snake. If Koko B. Ware can be in the Hall of Fame, how is Macho Man not in the Hall of Fame?

I think Bruiser Brody should be in the Hall of Fame

Bruiser and Macho both deserve a spot. It's a shame Bruiser was taken away the way he was. I was a big fan of his.

I think eventually they both will be put into the Hall of Fame, but they would have to be sober first maybe after they both went through the WWE rehab program, which could cause positive publicity.......I also think that the Freebirds or the Midnight Express should be in the Hall of Fame

Look I think the all the Godfathers of Hardcore Wrestling deserve to be in there I know i said brody already. But Abdullah The Butcher and The Sheik deserve there spots in there.

The Sheik is in the Hall of Fame

Oh well then the other two are the only ones missing.

Randy Savage deserves a spot.

Just wait til the druggies and alcoholics die THEN put them in.

Oooooohhhh yeah!!!!!!

Maybe Warrior? He has a shit ton of baggage with him, and he only contributed for a very short period of time.

If a wrestler is known for their problems (Roberts, Hall) then they will NOT go into the HoF while they're alive. If they die at the hands of their vice then they'll have to wait a few years to go into the HoF. Now if they were to die in a non-drug related accident, then they could go into the HoF before rigor sets in.

[/thread]

I have found some footage that has compelled me to become not only a believer in Goldberg as a Hall of Famer, but has turned me into a Goldberg mark. Here is the footage:

http://www.gifsoup.com/view/49515/fdsfds-o.gif

I am not sure Scott Hall is a Hall of Famer anyway. To me he doesn't pass the name test. Jake Roberts, I think he should go in. There are so many guys in the Hall of Fame that have done drugs, I don't think it will matter.

Scott Hall is in. When people think of the N.W.O. most people say Hall, Nash, and Hogan. He was a key piece of a group that changed wrestling on the business side and in terms of presentation of stables and how characters were portrayed. Everyone from Eric Bischoff to Jim Ross has praised his "mind for the business."

There's a reason he was given so many chances in WCW despite being a fuck up. There's a reason WWE brought him back and gave him another chance despite him being a fuck up (and don't say it was because he had his friends working in the WWE because if that was the case Lance Cade, Brian Kendrick, and Paul London would never have been fired). There's a reason TNA decided to give him a third chance (okay maybe this is because Dixie can't say no to the boys...)

The guy had the talent, he had the skill on the mic, and anyone who says he isn't hall of fame worthy is letting his actions from the past 4 or 5 years cloud their judgment.

That has to be the greatest thing I have ever seen.
I also recall Goldberg destroying Rodney Mack in the "white boy challenge..." ...which was a win for white guys everywhere...

I wonder if they'll let Chris Benoit in the HOF ?






































:shifty:

(that shifty was so 2003, I know. Fuck you)