Rank these female singers

[Kane Knight]

Originally Posted by Penner This is such a stupid way to argue. Your analogies are so ridiculous. This doesn't prove your point at all.

It's not intended to prove my point, so much as demonstrate that when someone makes false claims, I tend to view them as wrong, because false equals wrong.

In terms you can understand, "stupid claims are stupid. When people say stupid things, it's hard to treat them seriously."

Req's covered it pretty well, but she's a REAL vocalist only in the sense that anyone who sings is a REAL vocalist. She spends a lot of time at the top and bottom of her range, and she strains with both. I mean, everyone does it occasionally, especially live where your range can be artificially confined, but to do it constantly....That's bad. A real vocalist shouldn't be doing that. A real vocalist should probably nail the transition bits, too.