SMACKDOWN 11/21/17 THREAD The Bludgeon bros what else do you need

[Evil Vito]

Originally Posted by Noid They could very comfortably get up to 25 without these call-ups. And if they couldn't, then why do it?

If you assume the champs wouldn't be in:

Alicia Fox
Asuka
Bayley
Dana Brooke
Mickie James
Nia Jax
Sasha Banks
Becky Lynch
Carmella
Lana
Naomi
Natalya
Tamina

That's only 13 women on the active roster, one of whom being Lana who seldom wrestles. Paige's return and the 5 call ups bring it up to 19. You could have Nikki Bella or Lita or somebody else in that 20th spot.

I'm not saying I'm all that interested in a women's Rumble, but I could see it happening and these moves could be a prelude for it.

Personally I'd say the match would lose a bit of steam since there's a 100% chance Asuka would win so it would have an air of predictability over it, but still.

[Mr. Nerfect]

Originally Posted by #BrotherVito DELETED If you assume the champs wouldn't be in: Alicia Fox Asuka Bayley Dana Brooke Mickie James Nia Jax Sasha Banks Becky Lynch Carmella Lana Naomi Natalya Tamina That's only 13 women on the active roster, one of whom being Lana who seldom wrestles. Paige's return and the 5 call ups bring it up to 19. You could have Nikki Bella or Lita or somebody else in that 20th spot. I'm not saying I'm all that interested in a women's Rumble, but I could see it happening and these moves could be a prelude for it. Personally I'd say the match would lose a bit of steam since there's a 100% chance Asuka would win so it would have an air of predictability over it, but still.

I set out a random one one day and got up to 25 quite comfortably. I had Beth Phoenix, Molly Holly and Victoria in as surprises. I also gave Sara Amato a spot as a nice little thank you for her training work. It's very easy to fill the spots.

I think it would have a certain interest edge over a male Rumble, since they've never done it before and you know they have to go elsewhere for talent. That being said, I think two Rumbles on one show is a bit much. Just let them have their own way of developing contenders, or do a Women's Rumble at a different time of the year.